Rate these fighters from A+ to F-

[Walt Liquor]

In terms of their current overall boxing ability

Manny Pacquiao-A+
Floyd Mayweather Jr-A+
Paul Williams-B+
Juan Manuel Marquez-B+
Chad Dawson-A-
Timothy Bradley-A-
Sergio Martinez- A
Juan Manuel Lopez- B
Shane Mosley-B
Bernard Hopkins- A-
Miguel Cotto- B
Israel Vazquez- B-
Rafael Marquez- C+
Ricky Hatton- C
Amir Khan- B+
Paulie malignaggi- B-

Thanks

heres mine

[pbftxrs316]

to give mayweather anything less than an A+ is hysterical---to give manny anythng less than an A is too funny to me-----and who the hell ranked hatton currently over anybody? hatton is one of the worst shaped fighters ever----for him to be so rugged in the ring and so potentially great, he ****s himself up by getting out of shape and it hinders his ability against the top fighters---it's sad---i would rank paulie and cotto over hatton today---meaning currently---hatton isn't even fighting anymore----

paulie's win over diaz in the rematch and i felt he won the 1st fight also is better than any win hatton ever had, including castillio----hatton imo is the overall greater fighter but currently, hell no----and it's really fault---he could have been so much better---sorry, i like hatton, but he pisses me off with his lack of dedication to his conditioning----i've never see a fighter balloon up the way hatton has---he looks sick----for the mosley/mayweather weigh in---it was incredibly sad to see the shape hatton was in---and then he cried over the mayweather and pacquiao losses----stop whining ricky, and stop drinking so much----you lost to manny not because of floyd sr, he gave you the perfect gameplan and told your dumb ass to stop drinking so much, and you didn't listen to him---i bet had that been floyd in there that night, manny would have gotten the **** beat out of him------that i do know

anyway

hopkins-A

jmm-A

malanaggi-B

cotto-B

hatton-B-

vasquez-A

r. marquez-B+

williams-B

martinez-B+--almost an A--i have to see how he looks against williams again and maybe another slick fighter---

dawson-A--borderline A+---i want to see him fight hopkins---

mayweather-A+---if there was a A++ option---i would choose that for him--he's the only complete fighter on this list---he is the most skilled all around the board---

bradley-B+----

pacquaio-A---he's not a complete fighter---but what he does is special--but, he does get hit too much

lopez-B---he goes up and down to me----

khan-B---only reason---he hasn't been tested enough---let's see him fight bradley and alexander---then---he may jump straight to an A with me---but he's getting there----he's very close to an B+/A fighter---he has the skills of those grades, just not the test yet----

mosley-B+/A---he did get dominated against floyd, but he did dominate the ww champion in margarito----i don't bash him for losing to floyd like he did---i don't see anybody at ww or jmm beating floyd, period----so that's a testament to floyd's skillset and a testament to the grade i gave floyd----shane is still a great fighter and he has proven this----he has great skills----and manny ducked him twice, so that alone, proves his greatness----

[BritishBoxing92]

Manny Pacquiao - A+
Floyd Mayweather Jr. - A+
Paul Williams - B+
Juan Manuel Marquez - A+
Chad Dawson - B-
Timothy Bradley - B+ (Could be an A+ easily we will see)
Sergio Martinez - A
Juan Manuel Lopez - A
Shane Mosley - A+ (Prime of course)
Bernard Hopkins - A+ (prime)
Miguel Cotto - B+
Israel Vazquez - A
Rafael Marquez - B+
Ricky Hatton - B
Amir Khan - B-
Paulie malignaggi - C+

i second that...

[DR.ORGYY]

in terms of their current overall boxing ability

manny pacquiao
floyd mayweather jr.
Paul williams
juan manuel marquez
chad dawson
timothy bradley
sergio martinez
juan manuel lopez
shane mosley
bernard hopkins
miguel cotto
israel vazquez
rafael marquez
ricky hatton
amir khan
paulie malignaggi

thanks

manny pacquiao- a+
floyd mayweather- a+
paul williams- b
juan manuel marquez- a
chad dawson- b+
timothy bradley- a
sergio martinez- a
bernard hopkins- a
miguel cotto- a
israel vasquez- a
rafael marquez- a
ricky hatton- b+ (he only lossed to the best)
amir khan- b
paulie malignaggi- b.....................

[wazaa.]

In terms of boxing ability:

Manny Pacquiao A+
Floyd Mayweather Jr. A+
Paul Williams B
Juan Manuel Marquez A+
Chad Dawson B
Timothy Bradley B
Sergio Martinez B
Juan Manuel Lopez B
Shane Mosley B+
Bernard Hopkins A
Miguel Cotto B+
Israel Vazquez B
Rafael Marquez B
Ricky Hatton C
Amir Khan B+
Paulie Malignaggi B

[BOLLOCKS]

Manny Pacquiao - A
Floyd Mayweather Jr. - A+
Paul Williams - B
Juan Manuel Marquez - B
Chad Dawson - A
Timothy Bradley - A
Sergio Martinez - A
Juan Manuel Lopez - B+
Shane Mosley - B+
Bernard Hopkins - B
Miguel Cotto - B+
Israel Vazquez - A-
Rafael Marquez - B
Ricky Hatton - B
Amir Khan - B
Paulie Malignaggi - C

[Roy Keane]

Manny Pacquiao A
Floyd Mayweather Jr. A+
Paul Williams B
Juan Manuel Marquez A
Chad Dawson B
Timothy Bradley B
Sergio Martinez B
Juan Manuel Lopez B
Shane Mosley B
Bernard Hopkins B
Miguel Cotto B
Israel Vazquez B
Rafael Marquez B
Ricky Hatton C
Amir Khan C
Paulie malignaggi

[Walt Liquor]

Manny Pacquiao A
Floyd Mayweather Jr. A+
Paul Williams B
Juan Manuel Marquez A
Chad Dawson B
Timothy Bradley B
Sergio Martinez B
Juan Manuel Lopez B
Shane Mosley B
Bernard Hopkins B
Miguel Cotto B
Israel Vazquez B
Rafael Marquez B
Ricky Hatton C
Amir Khan C
Paulie malignaggi

WTF!!!!!!!! All over the place you are..

[THE_BIG_HURT]

Manny Pacquiao-A+
Floyd Mayweather Jr.-A+
Paul Williams-B+
Juan Manuel Marquez-B+
Chad Dawson-B
Timothy Bradley-B+
Sergio Martinez-A
Juan Manuel Lopez-B+
Shane MosleyB-
Bernard Hopkins-B
Miguel Cotto-B+
Israel Vazquez-C+
Rafael Marquez-C+
Ricky Hatton-C-
Amir Khan-B
Paulie malignaggi-D+

thats my story...

[Idgas]

Manny Pacquiao B-
Floyd Mayweather Jr. A+
Paul Williams B-
Juan Manuel Marquez A
Chad Dawson A
Timothy Bradley A
Sergio Martinez A
Juan Manuel Lopez A
Shane Mosley B-
Bernard Hopkins B
Miguel Cotto A
Israel Vazquez B-
Rafael Marquez A
Ricky Hatton B-
Amir Khan A
Paulie malignaggi A