Greater Fighter, Marvin Hagler Or Floyd Mayweather?

[deliveryman]

This question really isn't fair considering Floyd is still active.

Right now, I think it's pretty even.

A victory over Pacquiao places him above Hagler, and a title at Middleweight puts him in the top 10, IMO.

[PH|L]

I got Hagler top30, Floyd top40.

Hagler > Floyd.

[Sugar Ram]

Floyd vs hagler would have been a great match up to watch..

[Drunk Punch]

Hagler for me.

[jri9d0]

Mayweather's career isn't over.

Yeah your're right, he'll just retire after the competition heats up again...

[them_apples]

Hagler has ATG's on his resume, Floyd is ducking the ATG of his era.

[Da Hammer]

Hagler is being underrated if we are really comparing their ATG status...

[Hannibal Barca]

Hagler has ATG's on his resume, Floyd is ducking the ATG of his era.

He's ducking himself?

[£-4-£]

Mayweather's career isn't over.

precisely.

the poll says who will be 'remembered' which is past tense. meaning after Mayweather's career is over how will he compare to Hagler.

Obv we don't know what's going to happen, but i think he'd beat Pacman. He'd also beat Martinez, Bradley, Alexander, Margarito, Berto and Williams if he ever got into the ring with any of them.

So I chose Mayweather. If he were to beat Pacman, then a bigger man in Martinez and then a young, hungry up-and-comer like Bradley, then its game over.

[jri9d0]

precisely.

the poll says who will be 'remembered' which is past tense. meaning after Mayweather's career is over how will he compare to Hagler.

Obv we don't know what's going to happen, but i think he'd beat Pacman. He'd also beat Martinez, Bradley, Alexander, Margarito, Berto and Williams if he ever got into the ring with any of them.

So I chose Mayweather. If he were to beat Pacman, then a bigger man in Martinez and then a young, hungry up-and-comer like Bradley, then its game over.

Yes, key phrase "if he ever got into the ring with any of them" otherwise we would never know right?