Who will be remembered as the greatest of these fighters?

[The Hammer]

I think Oscar, he was the only one to win gold for the USA in the Olympics and he accomplished a lot as a pro. The version of Oscar who lost the SD to Floyd was past prime.

And Oscar was far more popular than the others, he was a household name even here in English Canada where boxing has a low profile.

[Boxin']

I say DLH. For some reason people tend to love to **** ride him even though he lost 90% of the big fights he's ever had.

Those 10% of big fights that he won are more big fights than Floyd Mayweather has had.

[Boxin']

I think Oscar, he was the only one to win gold for the USA in the Olympics and he accomplished a lot as a pro. The version of Oscar who lost the SD to Floyd was past prime.

And Oscar was far more popular than the others, he was a household name even here in English Canada where boxing has a low profile.

You are kidding yourself.

DLH wont be remembered as greater than Floyd and RJJ. You know that Oscar wasn't even close to winning when he fought Floyd.

[Kagami Taiga]

Those 10% of big fights that he won are more big fights than Floyd Mayweather has had.

stop trolling. if u think this is true then u havent followed floyd's career.

[The Hammer]

Most people think Floyd, but he's never really had a career-defining win yet.

He needs Pacquiao.

[B.U.R.N.E.R]

Most people think Floyd, but he's never really had a career-defining win yet.

He needs Pacquiao.

Corralles?

Oscar at 154?

Mosley at 147?

[baracuda]

win over pernell and chvez ****s on anyhting roy , bhop,and floyd have ever done... .....

[-EX-]

Roy or Floyd...5-10 years from now it'll be Floyd...15-25 from now probably Roy...

[clmags12]

All 4 have accomplished alot in boxing, but it will be Oscar who will be "remembered" by the general public.
His Olympic Gold, his pro fights- even if he didn't win them all he still fought and was game. Thats respectable enough.

[Scott9945]

win over pernell and chvez ****s on anyhting roy , bhop,and floyd have ever done... .....

Both of those wins were over great champions who were well past their prime. Hopkins beating Trinidad was better.