Who will be remembered as the greatest of these fighters?

[The Hammer]

Of the four American boxers on the list, who will be remembered as the greatest?

[S.G.]

Right now it's pretty much a toss-up between Floyd and Roy Jones, but I think by the time all's said and done Mayweather will be above him.

[B.U.R.N.E.R]

Its only between Floyd and Roy.

Floyd will be remembered as greater. Floyd stil has some fights left.

[wazaa.]

Its only between Floyd and Roy.

Floyd will be remembered as greater. Floyd stil has some fights left.

This. Yo No Ceilings, I noticed that I agree with you alot.

[d0n]

Roy Jones Jr. just has a ring to it. I don't think people in the future will care about what he didn't do, but rather only focus on what he DID do. Out of all of them guys, Roy is the most popular under the normal people...you know, people who arn't into boxing...like never watch it or care who fights when...don't even know Manny? They know his name.

[Kagami Taiga]

floyd has the best chance, if only because hes the one still fighting and he has some potentially big fights ahead. its all up to him, his legacy is in his own hands whereas those other guys, the book is pretty much closed on them.

[Boxin']

This. Yo No Ceilings, I noticed that I agree with you alot.

that's not a good sign...

[Boxin']

Roy Jones jr. and Floyd Mayweather were both cherry pickers.

[T-97]

It's between Mayweather and Jones, it all depends on what Mayweather does before he retires. Right now, it's Jones. But who knows what will happen in the next few years.

[FightMoney]

I say DLH. For some reason people tend to love to **** ride him even though he lost 90% of the big fights he's ever had.