More Dominating? MANNY vs Oscar or FLOYD vs Shane?

[El Chicano]

Thats a pretty silly question, but now i gotta ask who was more dominant

Floyd vs Marquez
Pacquiao vs Marquez?

What would have Manny done to the slow, fat 144lbs version of JMM?

Or perhaps a better question is, what would have Manny done to Shane on May 1st, 2010?

[solo20]

it depends how you look at it i pick moslye becaues he was not weight drain funny how Pac was the bigger man that night he fought Oscar i always laugh at it when i think about it wahaha

[gibo]

sorry, i don't count that fight with de la hoya a huge win. dude could'nt even lift his arms from the weight drain. the use of IV bags to rehydrate is an obvious sign de la hoya was'nt even 25%. now if it was at jr middle (de la hoyas) normal fight weight and pac did the same thing, that would be another story. my vote goes to the shane fight. sorry i'm just putting proper logic into play here.

So let me get this right. You wanted Manny who had never fought at 147, and had only fought at 135 one time, come up to 154 to fight delajoya???? Hoja had no buisness challenging such a small fighter! The fight was made only cause hoja and ONLY hoja could convince the boxing commissions to make such a fight happen!!! ($$$$$CASH$$$$$) The truth is It blew-up in hoja's face. Not money wise, but outcome wise!!!! He made lots of money, but got his ass whipped BAD by a very much smaller fighter he was suppose to beat!! P.S. I truely don't think he cares he lost to Pac. He's still counting his earnings for that fight!!!!!!!! hoja set the con and fans like you couldn't see it, and fell for it!!!! LOL..... it happens!!!!!!!!!!!!

[DR.ORGYY]

Manny by far........

[gibo]

de la hoya was dehydrated weigh in 145 looking like a gohst and fight night weigh in at 147 before the fight having IV on his arms you *******s are ****** by asking this question what kind of credit is that beating a old washed up dehydrated fighter?

Who asked for the fight? Didn't fight Cotto or Margarito, ONLY asked to fight Pacquiao!!!! Then got OWNED and QUIT against the Pac-Man!!!! The worst mis-match in the history of boxing and hoja gets blasted out then QUITS!! So much for your hero.......

[Cash Cow]

pac would beat any opponent in floyds resume better...

but would he take less punishment?

[Cash Cow]

the shane that showed up to fight floyd would have been murked by manny.

"Shane came to the gym twice to ask me to let him fight Manny," Roach says. "I told him no both times, and both times for the same two reasons: First, there isn't enough money there, and second, you're too good a fighter."

now STFU

[Mickey Gomez]

It's a tough (but good) question. Manny overwhelmed Oscar with pure athleticism. Floyd embarassed Shane with slicker boxing. It's a toss up but in terms of dominating the opponent I'd have to lean towards Pac v Oscar.

[check hook]

Can't handle the truth, little boy?
DLH did a lot better than Mosley when they fought Mayweather.
He was fair game when he fought against Mosley and Forbes, then when Pac busted his gut, he's shot? Get the **** out of here.
You can look at it any way you want it, but Pac would have abused Mosley if he fought him May 1st.

That may or may not be true.....but remember Freddie Roach told him he isn't getting the fight because he is "too good" so i guess we will never know.

So you are on here claiming ODLH that fought Pac was just as good as the version that fought Floyd???

You *******s are a sad bunch..........

[STRUGG]

That may or may not be true.....but remember Freddie Roach told him he isn't getting the fight because he is "too good" so i guess we will never know.

So you are on here claiming ODLH that fought Pac was just as good as the version that fought Floyd???

You *******s are a sad bunch..........

like we wouldnt know......who would win between floyd v.s......COTTO...........MARGARITO................ .and prime shane Mosley.............