More Dominating? MANNY vs Oscar or FLOYD vs Shane?

[Ragnar Lothbrok]

hahaha...this should be a thread....LIKE NOW!

Not quite..........................

it helps when floyd fought marquez at welterweight & at 36 years old coming off 3 wars in a row vs pac, casa, & diaz compared to when a one handed, raw/green pacquiao took on marquez when marquez was at his absolute physical prime at 126. Even the rematch at 130 with marquez coming off a win vs barerra was a much fresher & healthier & fairer fight than the marquez that floyd won.

both fight that pac took on marquez means much more than that abomination fight that floyd won.

[check hook]

Manny was more dominant of course.

But, Floyd fought the much better opponent.

That version of Shane> That version of Oscar.

That version of Shane also stops that version of Oscar.

Hell Floyd stops that version of Oscar if he really wanted to. I think Floyd could of stopped the 154 pound version of Oscar if he really pushed it.

Floyd would have stopped the version of oscar Manny fought aswell....actually any good welter would have.....he couldn't do anything.....move, defend or get off.......it may upset Pac fans, but it is glaringly obvious.......ODLH couldn't have beaten any good welter that night....he was just emaciated.

To the casual fan the win over oscar is more dominating, but when placed into perspective of where both opponents were at the more astute observer would say a 10-2 beat down of Shane was more dominating.

[SonOfCuba]

Easy, look at the way Oscar did against Floyd and the way Manny dominated him

I can only image if Pacman fought Mosley right now.

[check hook]

Mosley and DLH were both pretty much shot during their last fights.

Pac clearly dominated more.

so Molsey was shot now.......are you listeneing to yourself.......welcome to ignore.......that is complete and utter tripe.

[check hook]

Easy, look at the way Oscar did against Floyd and the way Manny dominated him

I can only image if Pacman fought Mosley right now.

you really have no understanding of boxing do you???

I guess Berbick was better than Ali????

[STRUGG]

so Molsey was shot now.......are you listeneing to yourself.......welcome to ignore.......that is complete and utter tripe.

Mosley been shot since getting outboxed by mayorga................the margarito performance was one last hurrah...................

[Wreckless]

so Molsey was shot now.......are you listeneing to yourself.......welcome to ignore.......that is complete and utter tripe.

Can't handle the truth, little boy?
DLH did a lot better than Mosley when they fought Mayweather.
He was fair game when he fought against Mosley and Forbes, then when Pac busted his gut, he's shot? Get the **** out of here.
You can look at it any way you want it, but Pac would have abused Mosley if he fought him May 1st.

[Wreckless]

you really have no understanding of boxing do you???

I guess Berbick was better than Ali????

YOU have no comprehension for boxing.
At that night Berbick WAS better than Ali. Just like that night Floyd was better than the past his prime Mosley.

[cletoreyes147]

How was Mosley weight drained for the Mayweather fight?

[Ragnar Lothbrok]

so Molsey was shot now.......are you listeneing to yourself.......welcome to ignore.......that is complete and utter tripe.

the shane that showed up to fight floyd would have been murked by manny.