If Margarito rematches Shane, and wins,

[Crazylegs77]

how much credit does he get?

As much credit as Floyd unless he stops Shane then he gets a bit more.

[Eaner0919]

he will never fight in the u.s again so BOOK IT. mexico may support his behavior but in the U.S we do not support criminals who were willing to risk killing a person for sucess they couldnt achieve by fair means.

care to bet that?

[sicko]

Mayorgas style can never beat Forrest.

Run along to the rookie room or something.

Ok but Mayorga didn't get his ass kicked the first fight then come back the 2nd time and beat him, Mayorga beat Forrest BOTH times they fought so WTF does that have to do with Margarito and Mosley? we seen what happened when Margrito fought Mosley, did you see anything in that fight that made you believe that things would be different a second time around? Mosley hands speed was too much for Margarito and who the hell don't know that Mosley dominates fighters that fight coming forward maybe you need to head to the Rookie Room lol

[Sweet Pea 50]

I picked Marg over SSM, in a 12 round war. I never thought Marg would have got totally destroyed like that, at 147. I think Marg better shut the **** up, before Martinez start's asking for rematches.

[slickfox]

care to bet that?

I would If I had something tangible to bet with...I'm new here.

[Mr. Fantastic]

Funny how this thread is almost 4 pages and hardly any answers.

[Xyei]

I don't see this rematch ever happening but if it did and Marg won, I'd give him a lot of credit. To beat a guy after getting brutally KTFO is really something. I couldn't see Margarito winning against Mosley so I'd be really impressed and give him a ton of credit.

[Piper the Great]

idk my boy looked real life ****ty the other day

[nozorok]

If Mosley has to undergo random drug testing again I think Margarito will have a very real chance at beating Mosley. You all saw how awful he looked fighting Mayweather clean. Shane was out of gas in two rounds.

[Vasyl’s dad]

Funny how this thread is almost 4 pages and hardly any answers.

and there is it.

Most people can't even discuss a simple matter without getting emotional, so they have to bring up **** that has been discussed thousands of times already.

We know he was caught doing something that wasn't right. Fine. We get that.


Thats not the issue here though,

I asked a simple question,

If Margarito was to rematch Shane and win, does he get credit?




I think most don't want to truthfully answer and say no. They don't want to answer because then they'll have to remember that Shane is 38.


If they don't give Margarito credit, they'll have to renounce the credit gave to another fighter who just beat Shane.