If Pacman/Mayweather win what does it do for their legacies?

[lfc19titles]

The general opinion (neutral and *******s) (sorry if I am wrong here) is that Pacquiao currently is ahead of Floyd in the ATG list. Currently I believe it is fair to say Pac is in the top 35 of the ATG list

I also believe it is fair to say Mayweather is in the bracket of 50-60 in the ATG list. Now very rarely do you get two boxers near enough in their primes who are ATG who fight each other.

Since the fight is almost agreed as roach said with Arum flying to offer Manny the contract he agreed with golden boy, the question is where would a win for each fighter in a hypothetical sense take them in the ATG list?

[Boxin']

A Pacquiao win does more for his legacy because he is a former featherweight champ. He is also much smaller than Mayweather and is considered the underdog.

[infamous larryx]

a win over floyd does more than a win over manny....thats very true..so how is manny higher in the atg list than floyd?? beating floyd will be historic..beating manny will just be beating manny

[MOTHER DUCKER]

Both top 20 imo.. if they gain a win over the other..

I think they are pretty close right now, some of Floyds wins get underated abit.

[lfc19titles]

a win over floyd does more than a win over manny....thats very true..so how is manny higher in the atg list than floyd?? beating floyd will be historic..beating manny will just be beating manny

come on bro, I am a neutral and the quality of fighters favours manny. I am sure you can see that

anyway for you and others, where do you think a win would take them in terms of a number in the atg list@?

[lfc19titles]

Both top 20 imo.. if they gain a win over the other

fair enough, would you even say top 10 or is that too far?

[V.WEBB]

A Pacquiao win does more for his legacy because he is a former featherweight champ. He is also much smaller than Mayweather and is considered the underdog.

How is he "much" smaller than Mayweather?

[MOTHER DUCKER]

fair enough, would you even say top 10 or is that too far?

If Mayweather goes onto to take Williams/Martinez after (basically whoever is the mw champ) he would and i think he could do that, i don't believe Pac could fight as high as MW.

[Boxin']

a win over floyd does more than a win over manny....thats very true..so how is manny higher in the atg list than floyd?? beating floyd will be historic..beating manny will just be beating manny

Because Manny is a 7 division champ coming from a much lower weigh class.

[Boxin']

How is he "much" smaller than Mayweather?

The guy in your avatar looks 160 pounds.