Comments Thread For: Mayweather is Back: BScene’s Pound for Pound Top Ten

[Dick Buffman]

I was disappointed to see Wladimir Klitschko isn't even mentioned in the also-rans after the top 10.

Bot Vitali and Wladdy need top ten consideration.

[Sweet Jesus]

He's been off for about 8 months, lol...

Before that he was fighting every 6 months.

Well if you consider the Mayweather fight a farce, then it never happened. His last fight is Diaz I.

[Pullcounter]

it doesn't really matter if you got pac at #1 or floyd at #1. its all opinion anyway.

[THE REED]

I'm honestly not sure how Wlad isn't in the top 10...

[illmatickid]

[Boxingholic]

Mayweather doesnt deserver P4P #1, and will never will since he pretend retirement to skip Cotto, prime Mosey, Margarito, Williams. Just coming back and fighting past prime Mosley automatically makes him #1? WTF?

[trainhard_187]

First how does a fighter get top spot when he cheated another fighter on the scales, ex. Marquez vs. Floyd.. That aint no P4P status at all..

Now if Pac cheated anyone on the scales he would damned by the media all you haters..

But really this list is garbage anyways cause what really matters is who holds the fighter of the decade award.. and it aint Floyd..

[trainhard_187]

If you have to come in and weigh more then your opponent, not agree to the catch weight against a lightweight fighter and you claim to be a Welterweight. You aint P4P status.. end of story..

[wengz2002]

If Pac-Mayweather doen't come around next, I want Pac to fight Mosley!

So far Pac & May have defeat 3 common opponents...
But Pac wins are more punishing!

If Pac fight Mosley, I strongly feel he can Knock the old man out!
That Mosley that fought Mayweather will not last until 8th rounds!

[Rick Grimes]

First how does a fighter get top spot when he cheated another fighter on the scales, ex. Marquez vs. Floyd.. That aint no P4P status at all..

Now if Pac cheated anyone on the scales he would damned by the media all you haters..

But really this list is garbage anyways cause what really matters is who holds the fighter of the decade award.. and it aint Floyd..

If you have to come in and weigh more then your opponent, not agree to the catch weight against a lightweight fighter and you claim to be a Welterweight. You aint P4P status.. end of story..