Ring Magazine:Floyd vs Shane winner WILL NOT SUPPLANT P4P 1# Pacquiao

[jmah]

Rosenthal is just one vote of the forty or so on the panel. Pacquiao may remain P4P #1 on his ballot regardless of Saturday's outcome, but there's no guarantee that others will see it the same way.

[The Hate Giver]

missing the point bro a 39 year old mosley is better then a 29 Cotto according to the ring but my point is that since Floyd never lost his #1 title I could see an exception being made for him to regain his title with out actually fighting the #1 guy. beating the 2 and 3 best fighter in the world should be taken into consideration regardless of how old they were

of course. he just got beat by pac. cotto beat mosley before pac beat cotto what's your point?

add the fact that mosley got a damaged margarito you are looking at a severely overhyped shane mosley. he was one fight removed from struggling vs a corpse named ricardo mayorga.

at least cotto beat jennings & joshua clottey. he had a chance to take some warm up fights before he faced cotto. margarito went from a physically debilitating fight vs cotto straight to mosley.

trust me, when floyd is running around potshotting a slow & old looking mosley this saturday remember this thread.

[Jcsuper]

of course. he just got beat by pac. cotto beat mosley before pac beat cotto what's your point?

add the fact that mosley got a damaged margarito you are looking at a severely overhyped shane mosley. he was one fight removed from struggling vs a corpse named ricardo mayorga.

at least cotto beat jennings & joshua clottey. he had a chance to take some warm up fights before he faced cotto. margarito went from a physically debilitating fight vs cotto straight to mosley.

trust me, when floyd is running around potshotting a slow & old looking mosley this saturday remember this thread.

come on dude I dont know why youre hating Floyd so much thats pathetic. I hate the way you talk about Mosley and Marquez, two legends of boxing, with no respect, youre not a boxing fan at all, stop crying for a second.

And for the article, I kind of agree with the guys, Pac has done a lot lately and deserves to stay there, no matter who wins saturday. Also thats the main reason why we NEED to see Floyd Pac one day, to know who is really the p4p number 1.

[The Hate Giver]

come on dude I dont know why youre hating Floyd so much thats pathetic. I hate the way you talk about Mosley and Marquez, two legends of boxing, with no respect, youre not a boxing fan at all, stop crying for a second.

And for the article, I kind of agree with the guys, Pac has done a lot lately and deserves to stay there, no matter who wins saturday. Also thats the main reason why we NEED to see Floyd Pac one day, to know who is really the p4p number 1.

they are not legends. stop throwing that word so loosely.


LEGEND>ATG>HOF>

Marquez & Shane are not legends but Hall of Famers. All i said was shane is 39 off 1 year & 6 months & marquez was 36 years old career featherweight fighting a undefeated welterweight at welterweight.

[Pacquiao'd]

domination of shanebe floyd will put floyd bavk at P4P#1. watch

[carts]

floyd doesnt care he just want the money..

[The Hate Giver]

domination of shanebe floyd will put floyd bavk at P4P#1. watch

go date some imaginary hot japanese chick & talk about floyd & pacquiao.



sicko.

[Seleção No. 13]

For sure, everyone who tried to hype up the May-Mosley fight as the seat for #1 was truly pulling it out of their ass.

[guru]

the only way floyd gets #1 p4p in my book is if he totally dominates shane. ehither he KO's him or pitches a shut out. just winning a decision isnt enough to pass pac p4p

[j.one]

The winner will be the legitimate p4p #1 Pac gave up his spot by refusing to fight black americans refusing drug tests and fighting in EVENTS.