Floyd's resume Vs Paul Williams resume ? who will have the better legacy?

[B.U.R.N.E.R]

What up burner,

I agree that Floyd overall has a "better" resume. His battles with Gatti, Castillo, Corrales etc... How about @ WW?

A prime Marg is better then Floyds best WW win IMO.

Floyds assumed win over Mosley makes his WW resume elite.

Williams can reach HOF status. The only guy alive that can beat him is Martinez. Thats it IMO and he already holds a win over him.

Paul is slowly but surely building a great resume. Cintron is a Top 5 JMW.

[mrgreenfingers]

Fair enough...Williams shouldn't pick on guys shorter than him, but he does make weight, which is the requirement. Furthermore, Floyd shouldn't go into a fight heavier than a fighter who was already smaller to begin with.

ATG??? Didn't say he was...all I said was his resume continues to get better.
With that being said...he will possibly one day become a HOF.

you said it could be argued pauls last five fights are against better opponents than Floyds which is just, well, bull.

Williams

Martinez
Wright
Phillips (conveniently left out)
Kolle
Quintana

Floyd

Marquez
Hatton
De la Hoya
Baldomir
Judah

[Mr. Fantastic]

A prime Marg is better then Floyds best WW win IMO.

Floyds assumed win over Mosley makes his WW resume elite.

Williams can reach HOF status. The only guy alive that can beat him is Martinez. Thats it IMO and he already holds a win over him.

Paul is slowly but surely building a great resume. Cintron is a Top 5 JMW.

Pernell Whitaker was #1 P4P when DLH beat him and yet you give him no credit. You're so full of **** with your double standards.

[JBell11]

A prime Marg is better then Floyds best WW win IMO.

Floyds assumed win over Mosley makes his WW resume elite.

Williams can reach HOF status. The only guy alive that can beat him is Martinez. Thats it IMO and he already holds a win over him.

Paul is slowly but surely building a great resume. Cintron is a Top 5 JMW.

I agree, I won't say Williams is an ATG as the thread starter indicated. Williams will be HOF in no time. Martinez IS bad!

LOL You are too cool for school...Floyd's "assumed" win over Mosely. THAT I disagree with you on homie. But it's ok...may the best man win!

[JBell11]

you said it could be argued pauls last five fights are against better opponents than Floyds which is just, well, bull.

Williams

Martinez
Wright
Phillips (conveniently left out)
Kolle
Quintana

Floyd

Marquez
Hatton
De la Hoya
Baldomir
Judah

Oh my bad...that was a mistake....but it doesn't help the Floyd argument. Verno Phillips was a tough veteran fighter, during his hayday...noone could knock him out. Williams wth pressure and volume made Verno quit.

[F-22 Raptor]

Paul Williams lost to Sergio Martinez. lol at anybody who thinks that PWILl and FLOYD Mayweather can even be compared.

[STRUGG]

floyd did enough ..........in his younger days.........................to have a greater resume....................PWILL arguably loss to Sergio..........and didnt give CQ his rematch..................yeah and marg too................

[-GDS-]

For the recond, a prime Marg means a plasted Marg correct?

[mrgreenfingers]

Oh my bad...that was a mistake....but it doesn't help the Floyd argument. Verno Phillips was a tough veteran fighter, during his hayday...noone could knock him out. Williams wth pressure and volume made Verno quit.

point is his last five opponents arn't better than floyds, his last opponent was better but many people think he lost that so...

[JBell11]

Paul Williams lost to Sergio Martinez. lol at anybody who thinks that PWILl and FLOYD Mayweather can even be compared.

The point is Williams has a good resume, just like Mayweather in his own right has a good resume. I just happen to believe that P-williams will eventually have a better resume in the future. Win lose or Draw, is not the point. Martinez winning the Williams fight is irrelavant to the resume argument.

floyd did enough ..........in his younger days.........................to have a greater resume....................PWILL arguably loss to Sergio..........and didnt give CQ his rematch..................yeah and marg too................

See above

For the recond, a prime Marg means a plasted Marg correct?

What up GDS...Does it matter if Margo was "plastered" or not??? Williams beat him when noone else (including Mayweather) wanted any part of him.