should martinez be top 10 p4p??

[dans]

In my honest opinion, this is the true P4P list right now:

1. Mayweather
2. Pacquiao
3. Martinez
4. Williams
5. Dawson

This is based off my personal belief, not the percieved truth or what they've doen lately.

[Alec900]

yes like someone said 8-10

[Dirk Diggler UK]

So you compare the Williams-Martinez fight to Lewis-Holyfield 1? I think that pretty much shows how you view fights.

Nope. I just view fights and call them as I see them.

You follow whatever boxrec tells you apparently...

[Calilloyd]

Nope. I just view fights and call them as I see them.

You follow whatever boxrec tells you apparently...

Williams-Martinez was a close competitive fight. Holyfield-Lewis 1 was not. Apparently you call them how you want to see them

[daggum]

Why do people bring this sh** into a thread about Sergio Martinez? It's completely irrelevant, Manny Pacquiao and Floyd Mayweather Jr. aren't the only boxers on the face of the planet, everything doesn't revolve around them, they are not part of everything we talk about.

it is about martinez cause floyd takes up a spot on the list that martinez could potentially have. martinez fought the best 154 and 160 pound fighters in his last 2 fights and mayweather hasn't fought anyone who was the best in his division since castillo(lol if you say baldomir the journeyman)

my personal opinion is martinez should be much higher than floyd since he proved he can beat or at least compete with the very best. dominating no hopers or small fighters doesn't really prove you are one of the best fighters no matter how impressive you may look.

[Dirk Diggler UK]

Williams-Martinez was a close competitive fight. Holyfield-Lewis 1 was not. Apparently you call them how you want to see them

Which I gave to Martinez. Why are you so desperate for me to call it like you want me to?

[disolly]

I know it may seem a little bold, but I would have Martinez # 3 p4p after saturday night. I don't see how Mosley should be higher than Sergio.

[Calilloyd]

Which I gave to Martinez. Why are you so desperate for me to call it like you want me to?

My only issue is calling the fight a robbery which it was NOT.

[Dirk Diggler UK]

My only issue is calling the fight a robbery which it was NOT.

Where did I do that? Please show me.

Thanks.

[Calilloyd]

Where did I do that? Please show me.

Thanks.

I'm not saying you did but a lot of posters have. If you haven't my apologies for implying it. We can agree to disagree. You think he won it. I don't. I had it for Williams by 2 points. The 119-110 was way off but that doesn't mean Martinez won the fight in my view.