should martinez be top 10 p4p??

[Pullcounter]

I say top 5

top 5 is way to high. I'd put wlad in the top 5 before martinez.

[B.U.R.N.E.R]

top 5 is way to high. I'd put wlad in the top 5 before martinez.

Top 5 off one win is insane.

[daggum]

he needs top names like gatti, baldomir, or a lightweight like marquez to get on the damn list.

[B.U.R.N.E.R]

he needs top names like gatti, baldomir, or a lightweight like marquez to get on the damn list.

Damn you are a one trick pony.

[wazaa.]

8-10 range...........

This......

[Dirk Diggler UK]

Top 5 off one win is insane.

He knocked out Cintron, beat Williams and brutalised Pavlik.

[-Spinal-]

A win over the MW champ who was undefeated at 160. That's like Pacquiao's win over Hatton at 140 where Hatton was undefeated. Of course Martinez belongs at top 10 P4P.

[B.U.R.N.E.R]

He knocked out Cintron, beat Williams and brutalised Pavlik.

Out of those 3 names. The only W I see next to his name is Pavlik.

So we shouldve ranked JMM p4p Number 1 right because I think he beat Pac?

[-Spinal-]

He knocked out Cintron, beat Williams and brutalised Pavlik.

He did knock down Cintron but the Williams fight was too close to call a robbery.

[Dirk Diggler UK]

Out of those 3 names. The only W I see next to his name is Pavlik.

So we shouldve ranked JMM p4p Number 1 right because I think he beat Pac?

Yes but people who actually watch boxing read between the lines and dont just look at boxrec.

I personally had JMM over Pac for a long time because of that.