Comments Thread For: Carlos Quintana: "Andre Berto Was Just Too Good"

[-GDS-]

well on to bigger and better things for Berto how about a huge PPV battle vs Juan Diaz...



Quintana should move up to 154 and give it a few more fight and pack it in if he keeps losing.

Berto will fight the Adyin vs Collazo winner next, then maybe a fight with Cotto if he beats Foreman. IDK what Mosley would do if he lost to Floyd, and Q should maybe fight Cory Spinks after a few gimme fights if he can, or if he wanted to get a welterweight belt before moving up, he should fight Jan Zaveck.

[GRUSTLER]

I thought Carlos Quintana experience would be too much
for Andre Berto but Berto did his thing and much props
and cong**** to him. Curious on who Berto will fight
next but definitely think he should step it up.

[-GDS-]

I thought Carlos Quintana experience would be too much
for Andre Berto but Berto did his thing and much props
and cong**** to him. Curious on who Berto will fight
next but definitely think he should step it up.

He probably shouldn't fight Pac or Floyd next. So who do you think he should step it up against? The Adyin-Collazo winner? Cotto if he beats Foreman? Mosley immediately after his fight with Floyd?

[Mr. Philadel]

maybe he WAS too good for Quintana, maybe!!.....but he would get his head handed to him by Manny Pac, Sugar Shane or even Maragrito....Berto is NOT that good imo.....Collazo spanked him but not enough to win the fight but he did put a nice spankin' on him.....anytime Berto steps up in competition he'll get spanked....the kid squares up way too much.....his first lost will be by KO!!!....watch!!

[-GDS-]

maybe he WAS too good for Quintana, maybe!!.....but he would get his head handed to him by Manny Pac, Sugar Shane or even Maragrito....Berto is NOT that good imo.....Collazo spanked him but not enough to win the fight but he did put a nice spankin' on him.....anytime Berto steps up in competition he'll get spanked....the kid squares up way too much.....his first lost will be by KO!!!....watch!!

Maybe Pac, Shane or Floyd would beat Berto, but under controled conditions (i.e. non loaded gloves) Berto would beat Marg. Berto has a good bit he needs to improve on, but he's second only to the top three welters.

[BROOKLYN CESAR]

There were no excuses from former welterweight champion Carlos Quintana. He was stopped in eight rounds last Saturday when he challenged WBC champion Andre Berto. Quintana said Berto was simply a better fighter. He hit a lot harder than Quintana expected, and his defense was a lot better too. [Click Here To Read More]

No **** sherlock!!! No i have a lot of respect for Quintana he fights the guys no one else is willing to fight!!!

[jvsnypes]

I think Berto needs to consider getting a new trainer. Even with his victory, I see a lot of flaws.I have not seen him improve after his last 4 fights.He gets hit too much,he's off balance at times,he head hunts, and he doesn't seem to be mentally tough.He depends too much on his physical abilities and hasn't improved skill wise.A good move for him would be to go after Manny Steward or Freddie Roach, or even Brother Naazim.If not,he will never reach the next level.

[Afactor4]

Roach could be an ideal trainer for an aggressive guy with not so good defense like Berto.

[Laborer]

Berto better play it safe because he is not ready for none of the big names. and is lucky he didn't fight Mosley cuz he would of got KO'D. Mayweather and Manny would destroy him too. Berto really has no way to go. he can't fight a no name, and he can't beat Mayweather,Mosley,Manny, or PWill

PBF could easily UD Berto. Mosley, a tough fight but i think Mosley right now is too good for Him. P Will, not 147. Pacman? Now that's the fight Berto will win, easily. pac will be schooled and will be exposed as another mediocre fighter who got lucky, over-protected, and still very one-dimensional. His defensive skills is equivalent to his skills as a statesman, which is NONE!

[led]

I think Berto needs to consider getting a new trainer. Even with his victory, I see a lot of flaws.I have not seen him improve after his last 4 fights.He gets hit too much,he's off balance at times,he head hunts, and he doesn't seem to be mentally tough.He depends too much on his physical abilities and hasn't improved skill wise.A good move for him would be to go after Manny Steward or Freddie Roach, or even Brother Naazim.If not,he will never reach the next level.

i agree with ur post