Who are the top guys at Junior WW and why?

[flexxx145]

Yes you have Peterson ahead of Khan and Ortiz and I am the clown ok....

Khan has proved nothing with this win. People want to see him face a challenge. This was not that so I'm not impressed.

[jrosales13]

Malignaggi was not a A level fighter stop it pumping up this victory. This fight was Paulie's last shot at the big time. He proved that he was shot tonight. The only thing Amir proved to me is that he is better than a B list fighter.

How the **** am I pumping up the victory? Are you on dope?

Did you not have Paulie at #8? I never said A level fighter. I said lower top 10 guy. You had him at 8. So you had him as a lower top 10 guy

So lets try this again read carefully.

You're saying a damn near shutout lost to the best. Is better than a decisive stoppage victory over a lower top 10 fighter.

Is that what you're saying?

[jrosales13]

Khan has proved nothing with this win. People want to see him face a challenge. This was not that so I'm not impressed.

OK Khan hasn't prove **** with a win. What WIN does Peterson have that has proven more than what Khan and Ortiz has accomplished at 140?

[flexxx145]

How the **** am I pumping up the victory? Are you on dope?

Did you not have Paulie at #8? I never said A level fighter. I said lower top 10 guy. You had him at 8. So you had him as a lower top 10 guy

So lets try this again read carefully.

You're saying a damn near shutout lost to the best. Is better than a decisive stoppage victory over a lower top 10 fighter.

Is that what you're saying?

Peterson has gone on since then to Beat Fuller. Khan has beaten Paulie. If Khan beats Maidana or even Ortiz then I will have some respect. I'm not impressed at all.

[B.U.R.N.E.R]

Edited list:

[jrosales13]

Peterson has gone on since then to Beat Fuller. Khan has beaten Paulie. If Khan beats Maidana or even Ortiz then I will have some respect. I'm not impressed at all.

Ohhhhh well excuse me... I stand corrected obviously the Fuller win is better than the Paulie and Campbell victory...

This explains everything.

[flexxx145]

OK Khan hasn't prove **** with a win. What WIN does Peterson have that has proven more than what Khan and Ortiz has accomplished at 140?

Well he hasn't been KTFO like Khan or quit like Ortiz. Plus he hasn't shied away from tough competition like Khan.

[jrosales13]

1. Alexander
2. Bradley
3. Maidana
4. Khan
5. Guzman
6. Paulie
7. Peterson
8. Urango

I don't understand how Peterson and now even Guzman can be over Ortiz. And, I am not even an Ortiz fan.

[jrosales13]

Well he hasn't been KTFO like Khan or quit like Ortiz. Plus he hasn't shied away from tough competition like Khan.

Oh wait did Khan get KTFO at 140?

Are we talking about 140 rankings or P4P rankings?

[check hook]

1. Alexander
2. Bradley
3. Maidana
4. Khan
5. Guzman
6. Paulie
7. Peterson
8. Urango

No Ortiz??......i wouldn't discount him at this stage.........and if Guzman can rediscover the sort of form he showed against Soto he will be hard to overlook at 140.

To me it's premature to start ranking these guys......


1. Alexander and Bradley

2. Ortiz and Maidana

The rest....i don't know

..........


I'm not prepared to discount Judah yet either......he may cause some damage...