Hatton Pound for Pound?

[Manny_P]

the list aint very good. How the heck did Barrera and Pac get on #10 and Castillo way the **** ahead?

[Shaolin Bushido]

Now this is where things get interesting. Everytime a top fighter loses, all these media guys bump the opponent way up. Do you remember Tarver going into the top 5 and some places even higher like 3 or 2? Now where will the media and fans put Hatton after beating a guy who everyone had top 5, most had top 3, and some had #1? I think they wont give Hatton his respect.

Roy Jones looked completely washed up but no one was willing to admit it and they said that Tarver beat the best. Now Tszyu didnt looked washed up but watch how they try to make every excuse for him and thats why they wont move Hatton high.

Here is my list

1)Hopkins
2)Mayweather
3)Wright
4)Chico
5)Hatton
6)Castillo
7)R. Marquez
8)Zab
9)Morales
10)Toney
11)Ouma
12)MAB/Pac

I'd keep Hatton wherever he was before last night but in the interest of objectivity ... slide Toney to the end just behind Hatton.

[Brother Mouzone]

hatton's record is padded except for the win over tszyu one win does not elavate you to the p4p list this guy won't even leave manchester and never will..........this is the equivelent of boxers in the u.s not fighting out of their hometown ...

[markosg19]

i wonder if cotto beat tzyu less convincingly than hatton where you amrericans would rank him!! probably around 4 or 5...... yet you are sceptical to give hatton his props, typical!

[Shaolin Bushido]

i wonder if cotto beat tzyu less convincingly than hatton where you amrericans would rank him!! probably around 4 or 5...... yet you are sceptical to give hatton his props, typical!

Typical? Despite his win I just don't think he's all that. He's a tough kid and comes prepared but in terms of punching power, accuracy and all I just don't think he's better than several guys.

I do give him credit for his poise and ring generalship but only because of the home cookin ... he won't be allowed all that rough house ****, foulling and the like anywhere else but in England. He shouldn't be allowed to do it there, either. It's a foul! Against the rules. He should have been docked a point for that flagrant blow to Tszyu's balls. He lead with his head all night and committed several other fouls, nearly as flagrant as hte ball shot.

Poise and ring generalship, let's see if he has any outside of England.

[hitman7hearns7]

kostay also hit low one 2 occasions

and how many america fight outside of america???!!!

also about the rough fight style ....
for ****s sake this is boxing not a tickling contest boxers these days need to man up there in a fight not at the movies

[Shaolin Bushido]

kostay also hit low one 2 occasions

and how many america fight outside of america???!!!

also about the rough fight style ....
for ****s sake this is boxing not a tickling contest boxers these days need to man up there in a fight not at the movies

Whatever man. I don't really give a damn. They coulda had a ****en knife fight for all I care.

[Run]

Ranking Hatton ahead of Morales is the ******est **** I have ever seen on a boxing forum.



Never pay again for live sex! | Hot girls doing naughty stuff for free! | Chat for free!

[moochi]

Ranking Hatton ahead of Morales is the ******est **** I have ever seen on a boxing forum.

for god's sake, how can you rank him from one fight................let him score another big win or two and then he's in there.........was buster douglas put in there....or how about danny williams? or corey sander for blasting W Klit, or Brewster for doing the same...it doesn't go that way....

[Super_Lightweight]

hmm

Hatton deserves number 5 in my opinion, but probably no higher. You at least have to consider that Tszyu might not have been the BEST version of himself. However, he still looked very good and coming off a blowout victory of Mitchell would many thought would beat Tszyu. Hatton has owned a lot of fringe contenders, and then beat Tszyu. This is good enough for top 5, but not top 3 (yet).

Also, why not have Hatton over Morales. Hatton weighed 147 on fight night whereas Morales weighes 141, 6 lbs difference. You don't think if Hatton was naturally 6 lbs smaller that he could beat Morales? I do.