On Margo's Comback; Who is right? P Will or Cintron??

[Mr. Fantastic]

1 more year.

He needs his prime years ripped from him.

So you want him to have his prime years ripped so when he comes back he doesn't look as impressive. Then we will have idiots like you saying he needs the plaster right??


Well at least Margarito is trying to come back to the sport and fight everyone. Not retire for 2 years to avoid fighting the rest of the top WWs.

[B.U.R.N.E.R]

So you want him to have his prime years ripped so when he comes back he doesn't look as impressive. Then we will have idiots like you saying he needs the plaster right??


Well at least Margarito is trying to come back to the sport and fight everyone. Not retire for 2 years to avoid fighting the rest of the top WWs.

He needs 1 more year taken from him. He needs his prime ripped from him like he arguably did to Cotto.

[BritishBoxing92]

Who is right on this issue?? Cintron or Williams??? if your the Comish do you grant the lic back or no?? easy questions....why or why not? poll on it's way!


Excerpt from ESPN article

Many boxers are equally divided on the punishment for Margarito, who's expected to plead his own case Tuesday in Los Angeles.

Kermit Cintron, who was stopped by Margarito in April 2005 and again in April 2008 for the only two losses of his career, told The Associated Press last week he suspects Margarito had illegal wraps on his hands during their bouts.

"I think he had stuff in his gloves, [but] that's just my opinion," Cintron said, replying with an expletive when asked what he thought about Margarito being allowed to fight in Mexico. "You look at those losses, and I don't know how it happened. You guys saw what he did before they caught him."

Multidivisional star Paul Williams, who beat Margarito in a narrow unanimous decision in July 2007, has a much more conciliatory attitude.

"You don't have any proof," Williams said. "I don't think the man should be banned, because that's how he makes his living. I think he should pay a bigger fine, but you can't take away a man's livelihood when there's no proof he's been doing it every time."

i dont know what to say really...one side of me says marg should be banned for good..the other side says maybe he should be given a second chance if he does the following 1) Random Blood Tests Before Each Fight 2) Check his gloves and Wraps before every fight 3) Pay A Big fine for using plaster of paris in his wraps

[Mr. Fantastic]

He needs 1 more year taken from him. He needs his prime ripped from him like he arguably did to Cotto.

He did it to Cotto cause Cotto is made for him. Simple. Doesn't take a rocket scientist to see that.

That was one of the greatest displays of will to win I've ever seen.

[B.U.R.N.E.R]

He did it to Cotto cause Cotto is made for him. Simple. Doesn't take a rocket scientist to see that.

That was one of the greatest displays of will to win I've ever seen.

Im no Marg hater or nothing. I just think another year is just.

[BMWM3P]

He did it to Cotto cause Cotto is made for him. Simple. Doesn't take a rocket scientist to see that.

That was one of the greatest displays of will to win I've ever seen.

No it takes a blind nuthugger like youreself to not see what he did to Cotto was because he had plaster on his wraps. But your love for plasterboy will never allow you to admit it.

[Eaner0919]

ok, so will he still work with Cap during training camp? Cuz any work with that guy at all sours toughts on Margs. Now if he comes back he will be looked at so hard I cant see him cheating again, so he did his year that all they said then yes he sud fight again cuz he did his time. If the comish is gone let him fight then they sud its been a year...

no where did I say he was working with Cap

he is fired and Roberto Garcia was hired in Nov 2009

But this does make me think...wat if it was PEDs he was busted for? That cud have the same effect right...more power, speed, stamina. In the long run i wud have to say they are the same and I wasnt and am not callin for a ban on any of the guy who hav been busted for that

no I actually disagree even as a long time friend and supporter of Tony

if you take PEDs you are trying to enhance your own performance

trying to load your hands with something is an intent to harm

big difference IMO

[Mr. Fantastic]

No it takes a blind nuthugger like youreself to not see what he did to Cotto was because he had plaster on his wraps. But your love for plasterboy will never allow you to admit it.

Blind nuthugger?? Are you sure about that?? Maybe your ass needs to take a good look in the mirror.

You're just basing your opinion on just an opinion. Not me nor you know. But like I've said a million times to you sore ass losers......Cotto just needed to clinch and avoid those uppercuts lol.

[savorduhflavor]

I think Cintron is wrong.

It depends on what he's getting punished for....if someones arguing him getting a harsher punishment for the wrap thing with Mosley, then that's one thing.

But punishing him more for speculation on previous bouts is unlawful.

[Iceta Lives]

So you want him to have his prime years ripped so when he comes back he doesn't look as impressive. Then we will have idiots like you saying he needs the plaster right??


Well at least Margarito is trying to come back to the sport and fight everyone. Not retire for 2 years to avoid fighting the rest of the top WWs.

How is wanting a Cotto rematch and fighting Pacquiao wanting to take on all comers? He still has unfinisthed business with Mosley and Williams. He never utters those guys' names.