Does Gerald McClellan get placed higher than his credentials merit?

[alza1988]

I'm watching this preview now the Benn Mclelland .It says he's never been beyond 8 and i'm scratching my head thinking it's his first 12 rounder .Then it says 28 wins inside 3 rounds
https://<object width="425" height="...mbed></object>

[jonesy]

I know his story is tragic and very sad and boo hoo and all that, and it gets alot of coverage. I was wondering, do you think this fact blurs peoples judgement a little and causes them to place him higher than he actually deserves in the grander scheme of things? When you look at his record, you'd have to put him on a level with the likes of someone like Jeff Lacy, certainly nothing amazing.

Your an Arsehole.

[Earl-Hickey]

I never see Gerald rated that highly really.

I think he could mix it with anyone @ M/W S/M all time, not saying he wins against everyone, bu he has a good chance against anyone

[SplitSecond]

he knocked the **** outta julian jackson twice
and was on his way to knocking out benn

but the guy had problems upstairs, no one is overrating him
he could seriously have you wake up in the hospital 1 month after fighting him