Ring Magazine's Fighters of the Decade 2000s: Division by Division

[Mr. Fantastic]

Certain TR fighters get passes I guess. Marg's wins are questionable at best, and plaster or not, he wouldn't of even beat Clottey had Clottey not injured both hands. And in the only fight we know for sure Marg wasn't cheating, he was DOMINATED every minute of every round until the stoppage. I can't think of any other "Elite" opponent that Shane fought that was dominated so throughly.

Just like his stomach problems with Pac right?

[-GDS-]

Just like his stomach problems with Pac right?

Yet Clottey still landed more punches on Pac than Marg did on Mosley.

[Horus]

[B]



Lightweights

1. Floyd Mayweather Jr.
2. Jose Luis Castillo
3. Juan Manuel Marquez
4. Joel Casamayor
5. Diego Corrales
6. Nate Campbell
7. Juan Diaz
8. Paul Spadafora
9. Leonard Dorin
10. Julio Diaz

Junior Lightweights@130

1. Manny Pacquiao COMPLETE BULL****!!!!!!!!!!!
2. Floyd Mayweather Jr.
3. Juan Manuel Marquez
4. Acelino Freitas
5. Joel Casamayor
6. Diego Corrales
7. Marco Antonio Barerra
8. Erik Morales
9. Joan Guzman
10. Edwin Valero

Featherweights

1. Juan Manuel Marquez
2. Manny Pacquiao
3. Marco Antonio Barerra
4. Chris John
5. Erik Morales
6. Scott Harrison
7. Naseem Hamed COMPLETE BULL****
8. In Jin Chi
9. Steven Luevano
10. Robert Guerrero
[B]

THIS LIST IS BULL****.....!!!

[Roy Hobbs]

THIS LIST IS BULL****.....!!!

How? you have a problem with the 130lb pound rankings? You must be a mayweather fan. Before you have a heart attack i think you should read the thread title; 2000s p4p division rankings.

Floyd's 130 lbs Resume in the 2000s decade;

Gregorio Vargas 40-6
Diego Corrales 33-0
Carlos Hernandez 33-2
Jesus Chavez 35-1

If Floyd could have carried over some of his 90s win vs genaro hernandez, angle manfredy then maybe the list is wrong. Ring magazine figured Pacquiao's resume & caliber of fighters fought at 130 trump flodys;

Pacquiao's 130lb Resume in the 2000s

Erik Morales 47-2 (3x)
Hector Velasquez 42-10
Oscar Larios 56-4
Jorge Solis 33-0
Marco Antonio Barerra 63-5
Juan Manuel Marquez 48-3.

Floyd's majority 130lb reign came in the 90s. He only had 4 fights at 130 in the decade. Pacman's resume trumps floyd at 130 IN THE 2000s decade. Very understandable.

[Iceta Lives]

Its based on the decade. Since 2000, Margarito has beaten Sergio Martinez, Frankie Randall, Antonio Diaz, Andrew Lewis, Sebastian Lujan, Kermit Cintron(twice), Joshua Clottey and Miguel Cotto.

Who the hell has come near that in the decade??? Enlighten me. Weak resume my ass lol.

Since getting to WW in 06 Cotto has beaten Carlos Quintana, Zab Judah, Shane Mosley, Joshua Clottey.

So yea...they have every fucking right to be at the top than the other guys.

Shane Mosley had already blitzed Diaz in 2 rounds and Margarito went life and death with him. And over time his win over Clottey has become less impressive because both Cotto and Pac beat him. Randall, Lujan, and Cintron? Are you kidding me? Lol. Martinez was a good win, but it was a long time ago. Mosley deserves to be ranked over Margarito based on his win over Oscar while moving up in weight and let's not forget he beat Margarito head to head of course.

[jrosales13]

THIS LIST IS BULL****.....!!!

The WW ranking is the one that is really bull**** IMO.

[Iceta Lives]

And why shouldn't Paul Williams be ranked over Margarito? He beat him didn't he? Unless you want to hold Paul's loss to Quintana against him which I guess would be understandable.

[-Antonio-]

Floyd Mayweather the second best WW of the decade? Based beating Hatton and Baldy?

Mosle the third best JMW based on looking like **** against Oscar, losing to Winky twice, and getting a TD with Marquez? Is that a joke?

Toney would have **** on all of the guys on that cruiser list.

Williams should not be above Cotto either.

[The Hate Giver]

I hate this list.

A for effort though.

[-Antonio-]

Why do you guys think Margarito & Cotto are so entitled? Margarito had a horrible resume for the longest. He then also got beat by Williams, destroyed by Margarito, and was found to be a cheater. I dont get why you guys think he's clearly over everyone. Cotto meanwhile was just slaughtered by Margarito and slaughtered again by Pac. He also had a life & death struggle with Clottey who Pac killed and everyone clowns now. You guys act like that **** dont exist

Williams lost to Quintana who Cotto destroyed. I can see Manny and Marg ranked over Cotto. But Williams and Mayweather, no way.

If Mosley is ranked so high then what is a Cotto win over him, chopped liver? Especially with Mosley's JMW ranking this list just reeks of GB bias.