Is Amir Khan overrated?

[PH|L]

if you think Malignaggi will beat Khan, then obviously you'll think he's overrated since he is a huge favorite in this fight.

I think Khan handles Malignaggi in a wide decision, which is pretty much what the odds suggest. We'll be able to see if you underrated him or if I overrated him after May 15th.

[Isai]

YES 34 57.63%
NO 18 30.51%
Maybe 7 11.86%
the stats say it all(current stats)

[wazaa.]

Amir isnt overrated !! His skills are legit.

[Mr. Mandingo]

Why are *****s digging up past losses of boxers they dont like ?

[the niggest]

He has so many haters on here and people who say he is overrated... That at this point he is actually underrated.

[Rudie Cant Fail]

He is chronically underrated. He gets **** on in this forum for three main reasons.

1. His Pakistani/British background.

2. He gets blamed for the outcome of the Barrera fight.

3. He has the same training team as Manny.

None of the above has anything to actually do with boxing,and therefore you can just put it down to the usual partisan nonsense that flows in this forum.

[TOBYLEE1]

Funny how some ppl say how great he is by beating Kotelink for a title and then turn around and say he is to green for the top guys. So which one is it. He does have the tools to be a great fighter but let the guy get there first.

Young fighters lose sometimes on their way up, it happened to Linares, Ortiz, etc, you can't count them out cause a lost. Many fighters loss early and became great

[BritishBoxing92]

Why is Amir Khan so overrated? Isn't this the same guy who got ****d by Prescott? Now he's ducking mandatory defenses ,and paying off the officials to look the other way. He hasn't beaten anybody his whole career yet some think he is the most talented JWW out right now. In reality Amir Khan is still green with limited experience and will face the toughest boxer he has ever faced in the Magic Man Paulie. If he can get past the 140lb "gatekeeper" then he deserves a smidgen of my respect IMO. But Amir Khan will get demolished by Bradley, Alexander, or even Peterson right now at 140lbs. Oh and Maidana is still waiting for his shot Amir. How much is his rep deserved?

more like underrated....

[MOTHER DUCKER]

He isn't over rated i see so much **** riding of Alexander because he beat a contender in Urango albeit it impressively. Other then that he faced Witter who was old, coming of a loss from Bradley not long before and got injured and forced to quit.

Khan has beaten Kotelnik (the champ at the time), Paulie and Salitia + some decent Uk opposition