Carlos Baldomir + Zab Judah were the #1+#2 WW's when floyd beat them

[-MAKAVELLI-]

Well why dont you go look at all the p4p lists and ratings from different organizations, media companies, see if they are exactly the same.

so you can't tell JRo what rankings you're going off of?

[Kagami Taiga]

Why are we talking about 140? I thought we was talking about 147?

So again you not going by the Ring ratings then which ratings are you going by? You going by your own ratings?

If that is the case then I would go by my own rating to and say Judah was even in the top 3 WWs at the time.

And, my ratings are just as good yours no worst no better.

you can go by ring ratings but no one was calling for him to fight margarito. thats a fact. ppl still wanted the judah fight and there even more who thought he was dodging baldomir. no1 knew who margarito was and the ppl that did werent calling for floyd to fight him. thats a fact, **** the rankings.

[jrosales13]

And, for the record Oscar De la Hoya was not the best 154lber at the time. He was rated #5 by the ring.

But, since you like to go by your own ranking.

In my personal ranking he was #6 at the time behind, Spinks, Karmazin, Ouma, Forrest, Dzinziruk

[daggum]

margarito was a top 3 welterweight for 6 years, was number 1 for 3 years, had been on hbo many times lewis, kyvelos, santos, and mayorga spinks, judah, baldomir and mayweather all ducked him. anything else?

[jrosales13]

so you can't tell JRo what rankings you're going off of?

That is cuz he is going by his own ratings.

[Equinox]

Why are we talking about 140? I thought we was talking about 147?

So again you not going by the Ring ratings then which ratings are you going by? You going by your own ratings?

If that is the case then I would go by my own rating to and say Judah was even in the top 3 WWs at the time.

And, my ratings are just as good yours no worst no better.

Because you are acting like you actually ordered that fight and would go online to look up daily updates for that fight... You also tried to belittle my boxing knowledge and you tried to act like you actually remember the ratings month by month. So tell me what were the ratings for April of 2007 for the 140lb division. You know you looked up thos ratings in recent times. I remember one true WW champion, the unified champ and that was Zab and every one knew it. There was no Margarito in the bigger picture no matter how many mandatories he beat, we all know mandatories are ****.

[-MAKAVELLI-]

That is cuz he is going by his own ratings.

cool...i had Fashan 3K Battery ranked at #1 when PAC used him as a tuneup

[paulf]

Dont waste your time. Anyone trying to discredit Floyd or Pac is just a nuthugger.

[-MAKAVELLI-]

Because you are acting like you actually ordered that fight and would go online to look up daily updates for that fight... You also tried to belittle my boxing knowledge and you tried to act like you actually remember the ratings month by month. So tell me what were the ratings for April of 2007 for the 140lb division. You know you looked up thos ratings in recent times. I remember one true WW champion, the unified champ and that was Zab and every one knew it. There was no Margarito in the bigger picture no matter how many mandatories he beat, we all know mandatories are ****.

nope, still dont see a source for the rankings in that post

[jrosales13]

you can go by ring ratings but no one was calling for him to fight margarito. thats a fact. ppl still wanted the judah fight and there even more who thought he was dodging baldomir. no1 knew who margarito was and the ppl that did werent calling for floyd to fight him. thats a fact, **** the rankings.

You want to say fuck the rankings fine but don't make up **** and say Zab was ranked higher than Margarito cuz he wasn't.