Why do you think Mosley can't beat Mayweather?

[Glamour Puss]

That is why they are called opinions.

No, I missed it . I watched and umm, let's just say that he may have to actually try this time.


Such as?

Castillo had a better jab since he actually commits to his unlike Shane who just flicks it out as a rangefinder for which he loads up his rights with.

Castillo had better footwork. Castillo was a better inside fighter.

Castillo had a more diverse offense and knew how to set up traps and walk you into big punches.

Shane does none of that. He relies strictly on his speed and power to break you down.

If you show him boxing skills you make him look helpless.

[IMDAZED]

Shane Mosley can't beat Mayweather because he is old and Mayweather is still Prime (As Floyd said it's more up here (Mind) then it is down there (Body), given that he excels in both and to think otherwise is dangerous.

Arcyani - I'm inclined to agree with you (and I lean towards Floyd in this one) but I don't know how "prime" Floyd is.

[B.U.R.N.E.R]

Well for what its worth Id take Shane at 135 over Castillo.

Anyway Shane couldnt get out of the way of Cottos jab. Thats still his Achilles hill.

[educator06]

One of the reasons Mayorga made Shane look so bad is cuz' Mayorga has good legs and good movement.

you are so wrong about this.... question,,,,how would floyd look against maryorga?

[DoubleMM]

If history in this sport PROVES anything... it's there can be a first for everything.

Nobody is unbeatable.

NOBODY.

Didn't say that. I jsut said that if he thinks elbows or clinching will wear Mayweather out it wont.

[IMDAZED]

Castillo had a better jab since he actually commits to his unlike Shane who just flicks it out as a rangefinder for which he loads up his rights with.

Castillo has a better jab. Agreed. Shane flicks a lot with his but he utilizes that pretty well by occassionally mixing a hard jab in there or following quickly with the right.

Castillo had better footwork. Castillo was a better inside fighter.

Completely disagree with first sentence. Second is spot on.

Castillo had a more diverse offense and knew how to set up traps and walk you into big punches.

Umm NO. Shane had the far better offense.

Shane does none of that. He relies strictly on his speed and power to break you down.

Yeah, because both Shane AND Castillo both didn't learn the trade sparring with Mr. Chavez

If you show him boxing skills you make him look helpless.

Right...

[Glamour Puss]

you are so wrong about this.... question,,,,how would floyd look against maryorga?

Probably crappy. Mayorga is a tough match for anybody.

[educator06]

In order to outbox Mosley you need to be able to outmuscle him, like Forrest and Winky were able to do. Which Cotto did extremely well also but couldn't sustain.

this ^^^^^^^^^

[B.U.R.N.E.R]

Probably crappy. Mayorga is a tough match for anybody.

At 154 hed outbox the Mayorga Shane fought.

[IMDAZED]

At 154 hed outbox the Mayorga Shane fought.

He would but Mayorga is extremely tough to look good against. And boxers have an extremely hard time with him. Just the facts.