Overrated Bad Decisions?

[jrosales13]

disagree i had oscar winning 9 rds

I had Tito winning 7 rounds... Oscar really did not win ever single round for the first 9 rounds...

[MoneyMayFan]

Winky-Vargas

No that was a robbery. Robbery because vargas was looked at as the next big thing. They couldnt have him lose against a no name like winky.

[Thread Stealer]

Sometimes it's the margin a fighter won by that bothers me rather than the decision. I don't have a problem with Leonard beating Hagler or Williams beating Martinez (I scored both 114-114). But Jo Jo Guerra had Leonard winning 118-110, and that one judge had Williams winning 119-109. That's just ridiculous.

[MoneyMayFan]

This one could go on and on. People always call fights "robberies" when they're really close.

Mosley-De La Hoya 2. PED use aside. DLH boxed well in the early going, Mosley got the better of it in the late rounds. There were many close rounds. Oscar's win over Whitaker too. That was a pain in the ass to score. A very close fight. People call Leonard-Hagler a bad decision, but that was a close fight that could've gone either way. Mayweather-Castillo 1 is greatly exaggerated. Castillo did very little in the beginning and gave away too many rounds.

Then of course you have people going "look at the Compubox", as if that amazingly accurate system means much.

This..People that didnt even watch the fight calls it a robbery because of hate.

and oscar got robbed vs tito...no doubt about it

[jrosales13]

No that was a robbery. Robbery because vargas was looked at as the next big thing. They couldnt have him lose against a no name like winky.

It was not a robbery. It was a fight that could of gone either way... And, Vargas was in crappy shape in that fight. But, still was competitive no way was it a robbery... It just a close fight that you could make a case for Winky winning. But, by no means was it a robbery.

[MoneyMayMafia]

Pacquiao-Marquez II

JMM spanked pac in that fight

[MARKBNLV]

I had Tito winning 7 rounds... Oscar really did not win ever single round for the first 9 rounds...

thats one of the great things about boxing people see things differently at times.

[jrosales13]

Sometimes it's the margin a fighter won by that bothers me rather than the decision. I don't have a problem with Leonard beating Hagler or Williams beating Martinez (I scored both 114-114). But Jo Jo Guerra had Leonard winning 118-110, and that one judge had Williams winning 119-109. That's just ridiculous.

I agree, I had Malignaggi beating Juan Diaz in the first fight. But, I scored it close. There were a couple swing rounds that if I would of went the other way. I would of Diaz winning the fight. So I ddin't consider the outcome a robbery like most people did. But, the scorecard was just horrible.

[Chunk..]

Froch - Dirrell.

[jrosales13]

JMM spanked pac in that fight

Dude it was a close fight there is no robbery... Tell me 7rds that JMM clearly won. Not rounds that were close or could of went either way. But, 7 rounds that JMM clearly won.