~~Post your Top 10 *ACTIVE* P4P Southpaws.~~

[jrosales13]

Good thread bro, And, I am not going to go by P4P. I am going by who I like most. So that is why my ranking might seem out of whack.

1. Pacquiao
2. Dawson
3. Valero
4. Williams
5. Hasegawa
6. Moreno
7. Kameda
8. Bute
9. Lopez
10. Martinez

[-Spinal-]

P4P no southpaw is better than Bad Chad Dawson imo. P4P he beats everyone on that list including Pacquiao, Wiliams, Bute, anybody. That's just my opinion though.

[Heru]

I don't even consider Calderon a lefty, he rarely has a southpaw stance. He just sidesteps, basically squares up (though not necessarily squaring up to his opponent), and throws punches from both stances.

Having Williams 4 spots in front of a guy that even the biggest Williams fan has to admit had a very close fight with is ridiculous.

[ummmid]

The p4p rankings are a joke.

American media favors American boxers.

Williams dosen't even deserve to be in the top 20. He's an overrated hypejob who picks on much smaller fighters. He has a heavyweight frame (6'3 82" reach), longer reach than the Klitschko Brothers (Wlad 81", Vitali 80") and he's picking on little men at 147 and 154...that's cowardly and pathetic. If Williams moves up and fights someone his own size he will get brutally KTFO.

Why isn't Martinez in the p4p rankings?

Martinez beat the **** out of the much bigger Williams and got robbed.

pound for pound not inch for inch.

[B.U.R.N.E.R]

I don't even consider Calderon a lefty, he rarely has a southpaw stance. He just sidesteps, basically squares up (though not necessarily squaring up to his opponent), and throws punches from both stances.

Having Williams 4 spots in front of a guy that even the biggest Williams fan has to admit had a very close fight with is ridiculous.

He had a close fight with him doesnt mean he should be ranked higher IMO. Martinez is a good fighter but his claim to fame is having a close fight with Paul. Not knocking him but if he beats Pavlik hes on the map.

[Heru]

P4P no southpaw is better than Bad Chad Dawson imo. P4P he beats everyone on that list including Pacquiao, Wiliams, Bute, anybody. That's just my opinion though.

P4P, I think Pacquiao outpoints him. Manny would just outwork him. Other than that, I see him beating everyone else on a P4P level.

Moreno is very underrated because he's not on TV and hasn't fought a name opponent, but as soon as he does, he will be up there on everybodies list.

[FromAfrica]

Yeah hes Top 15 IMO.

Guerrero
Navarez
Calderon
Rigondeaux
Komeda
Dirrell
Collazo
Quintana


Lot of good southpaws.

I like Fernando Guerrero.

[Ch@mpBox@PR]

I don't even consider Calderon a lefty, he rarely has a southpaw stance. He just sidesteps, basically squares up (though not necessarily squaring up to his opponent), and throws punches from both stances.

Having Williams 4 spots in front of a guy that even the biggest Williams fan has to admit had a very close fight with is ridiculous.

Is this Ivan Calderon we are talking about? WTF?

[Khalid X]

Pretty good topic because it made me have to think (and boxrec) but here is my list

1. Manny Pacquiao
2. Hozumi Hasegawa
3. Chad Dawson
4. Lucian Bute
5. Andre dirrell
6. Paul Williams
7. Juan Manuel Lopez
8. Sergio Martinez
9. Koki Kameda
10. Edwin Valero
11. Vic Darchinyan
12. Ivan Calderon
13. Devon Alexander
14. Anselmo Moreno (Im not gonna lie havent seen alot of him to make a fair assestment)

btw I did a top 14 because I felt bad leaving one of my favorite fighters (Darchinyan) and others outta my top 10.

I forgot to mention that my list is p4p in the sense of if they were the same size how would they be ranked if they fought each other.

[B.U.R.N.E.R]

How did almost everybody including me forget Alexander...lol.