If Shane beats Floyd, will Ring Magazine declare Shane as best P4P boxer?

[bongwater]

just throwin this hypothetical out there because it has to go both ways for all the Floyd fans saying he gets declared P4P crown if Shane loses

[Young Money]

If he can beat him decisively then I can see it happening

[The Surgeon]

Absaloutley, no question and he deserves it if he can beat Floyd

[pasawayako]

not until he beats pac.

[bojangles1987]

Pac isn't losing that spot unless he loses himself.

[HandSpeed303]

I can see him going to #2, not #1.

[Puck]

No... Floyd is rated #2 and Shane at #3 ... How can they declare Shane as the #1 p4p beating only the #2 ranked... Unless Pac losses to Clottey.

[RockyB]

they definately should. (if it isnt a SD or something really close)

[Frank Martin]

He could with these circumstances:

1. He beat Floyd and Pac loses against Clottey
2. He lose to Floyd but beats Pac
3. Beats both Floyd and Pac.
4. If Pac retires and he beat floyd

[$partacus]

He probably would, beating Mayweather would be bigger than anything on Pacquiaos resume.