Who fought a better version of oscar? FLOYD OR PACMAN

[Va_BoriKua]

Dela hoya's best weight in his prime is 147lbs and he was just a bloated fighter at the 154lbs so i'll say that pac fought a better version of oscar than floyd.

best version was at 147 and when was the last time he had fought at that weight? he had been fighting at 154 for years i mean he came in weighing 145 for the fight even roach said he saw the iv marks from them trying to rehydrate him when they were bout to fight.

[pasawayako]

best version was at 147 and when was the last time he had fought at that weight? he had been fighting at 154 for years i mean he came in weighing 145 for the fight even roach said he saw the iv marks from them trying to rehydrate him when they were bout to fight.

even though oscar didn't fight at 147 for almost 7 years he was still a small JMW. And how will you know that a 154 version of oscar is better than a 147 version of oscar can you give me one example that he's better than his 147lbs version.

[miron_lang]

154 I think. but you have to consider pac had 1 fight at 135

he's actually moving from Super Featherweight to Welterweight whila Oscar was 150 lbs againts Forbes so technically he's just moving down 3 pounds.



It should be 154 but Oscar Blames Manny for eating Kangaroo meat

[DiLLiNGER]

what a ****** fkn question.

[DiLLiNGER]

Pacquiao fought the better of Hatton as it was for the Lineal Title of Hatton's True weight.

Pac fought DLH where he was fighting at 130 at that time and had to moved up 3 divisions and dominate him.

Pac fought better because if Pac wins via Split Decision you call say the same thing that DLH is not shot.. Pac ****s on Floyd heavily and the only difference is Pac goes for the kill, Floyd goes for the marathon running from his opponent.

stfu u vagina,oscar looked like a corpse and hatton didn't look much better.

And hatton was unbeaten when floyd whooped him..after the loss hatton was just a shell.

[EL_cano]

Oscar was best at 147 by fighting Pernell and defending his wbc belt 7 times until he lost to Tito.

[Pepper]

Here you go

http://*******.com/y9vfw4y

lol. it's just excuses, he got totally dominated and humiliated in his best weight.

[ThePunchingBag]

They were about the same.

Only ODLH didn't overdo it in training camp and come in dehydrated against Mayweather.

I don't know why people keep blaming Pacquiao for ODLH's bad decision to overdo it and come in weight drained.

It was DLH's camps fault. A good trainer would know when to ease off the gas to maintain a good healthy weight.

[DARKSEID]

obviously floyd did.. why is this up for debate?

That's like asking who fought the better version of ali.. Cleveland Williams or Larry Holmes.

[check hook]

The fact we have 11 people voting YES that the version of Oscar who fought Pac was better than the version Floyd fought just shows we have some incredibly ******ed Pac fan boys on this forum.......i seriously cannot believe the ******ity.......eyes just glued the *** shut.........