Does a win over Mosley elevate Floyd to Manny Pacquiao status?

[B.U.R.N.E.R]

Warrant a 50-50. What does that mean?

[Shadow boxer 3]

Manny destroyed Oscar and Ricky... Floyd struggled with both.
Manny destroyed Cotto... Floyd ducked him.

Check yourself homie.

triangle theory dont mean ****. real boxing fans know this

[Doctor_Tenma]

Honestly, I agree, cuz the fight will probably be boring as HELL...

That doesn't even matter, a win is a win. To answer the question though, no it doesn't.

[Jamel H]

Manny destroyed Oscar and Ricky... Floyd struggled with both.

Manny destroyed Cotto... Floyd ducked him.

Check yourself homie.

U gotta admit though Oscar was FAR from the Oscar I grew up watching, Ricky wasnt the same after his first KO but I give full respect to Manny on his performance against Cotto he flat out beat him up

[Jamel H]

LOL Mayweather is fighting a 40 year old who got beat by Pac's last "has been"...what does that make Mosley?

Yea the same 40 year old that KO'd the guy who wasnt phased but any of Manny's last victims punches right?

[STREET CLEANER]

It would be all based on peformance, if Shane and Floyd fight a great fight and Floyd looks spetacular winning I would say yes, if he stinks the place up no, but he will remain the toughest challenge for Manny out there

[Jamel H]

It would be all based on peformance, if Shane and Floyd fight a great fight and Floyd looks spetacular winning I would say yes, if he stinks the place up no, but he will remain the toughest challenge for many out there

I agree, either way he'll still be in the top 3 if he wins...

[check hook]

You don't think he could of achieved that if Floyd stayed? If not why?

You think a floyd victory over Shane does not push him to number 1 again???

Manny is largely being blow up after beating ODLH, Hatton and Cotto.....well Floyd already beat much better versions of ODLH and Hatton....Mosley win covers Cotto and then some and he dominated JMM.........

Pac deserves his spot......you can't leave and expect to be number 1 again as soon as you come back but wins over number 2 and 3 P4P and undoubtedly the number 1 welter would push floyd to number one imo....


it has nothing to do with whether in peoples opinions the fight will be boring....


anyway this all assumes floyd beats shane....lets be real it's not going to be easy....

[LilFloyd]

lol no..pac >>> floyd even after his fight with mosley

[madsweeney]

Yea the same 40 year old that KO'd the guy who wasnt phased but any of Manny's last victims punches right?

If you just got busted for cheating, would you be going into the ring with a sound, confident mind? Or would you have your worries elsewhere? Not saying he didn't get what he deserves but dude was tailor made for Shane and he was fuct in the head for getting busted. Either way, thats the ONLY solid win Mosley has had in a while.