Who ranks higher ATG, Tyson or Calzaghe?

[#1Assassin]

tysons resume takes a **** on calzaghes any day of the week.

nobody is denying the flaws in tysons legacy, but its there cuz he took on all the best. he has some losses but with the number of quality wins he has he is still far above calzaghe, its not even close.

joes resume is weak.

[Dirk Diggler UK]

Calzaghe never had the balls to fight someone of the calibre of a prime Buster Douglas....lol

[General Zod]

I think he means top fighters when he fought them. Only big one I can think of that he fought that was a top fighter of recent is Hopkins. Fu(k the age excuses, that dude was STILL a top fighter.

Thats the problem when you insist on staying in one divison you end up fighting a lot of below average opponents. Joe should of moved up sooner imo.

EDIT: He needs Dawson, Prime Jones and maybe Pavlik on his resume to be closer

[General Zod]

Calzaghe never had the balls to fight someone of the calibre of a prime Buster Douglas....lol

Ice cold dude. That fight broke my heart when I was a kid

[Grimmer]

Undisputed heavyweight champion of the world, knocking out fully fledged heavyweights at 21 years old.

That is simply amazing....the keyboard warriors will nitpick, but if you were put in the ring with fully fledged heavyweight boxers when you were 21 you'd wither and die. What Tyson did was amazing.

[Dirk Diggler UK]

Ice cold dude. That fight broke my heart when I was a kid

Same here lol. Just having a laugh

[General Zod]

Same here lol. Just having a laugh

Yeah It made me laugh as well

[True Guru]

Tyson should have dominated well into the 90's,he really could have gone down as the very best IMO.
His decline was shocking and still amazes me to this day.

[Sick/]

Tyson is overrated

[General Zod]

Tyson should have dominated well into the 90's,he really could have gone down as the very best IMO.
His decline was shocking and still amazes me to this day.

In hindsight it really started after Cus had died, it could even be argued it started when he became famous. He just wasnt equipped to handle that kind of life. But hindsight is always 20/20 as they say