Mosley has a better resume then Floyd because he lost to Winky and Vernon?

[B.U.R.N.E.R]

A lost against a guy who had a great chance in beating you>a win against a guy who had zero chance in beating you.

So Andy Koelle has a better resume then Amir Khan. After all he fought Paul Williams and Andre Ward. Going by Walt Liquors logic.

[fabie]

So Andy Koelle has a better resume then Amir khan?

No, Blue is better than Red! (sarcasm).

A win is a win is a win. Obviously what can top Mayweather's 40-0 in "numbers"? Nada. But there's many more questions than answers that boxing purists and historians don't even consider him top 10 ATG.

Everything is relative. I am not totally discounting the value of Mayweather having an "undefeated" record thus far but that's not the issue.....40-0 is 40-0 no matter how you put it.

But the subjective part is where the questions begin to trickle.

[B.U.R.N.E.R]

No, Blue is better than Red! (sarcasm).

A win is a win is a win. Obviously what can top Mayweather's 40-0 in "numbers"? Nada. But there's many more questions than answers that boxing purists and historians don't even consider him top 10 ATG.

Everything is relative. I am not totally discounting the value of Mayweather having an "undefeated" record thus far but that's not the issue.....40-0 is 40-0 no matter how you put it.

But the subjective part is where the questions begin to trickle.

I never even mentioned him being undefeated as an argument.

[Cash Cow]

No, Blue is better than Red! (sarcasm).

A win is a win is a win. Obviously what can top Mayweather's 40-0 in "numbers"? Nada. But there's many more questions than answers that boxing purists and historians don't even consider him top 10 ATG.

Everything is relative. I am not totally discounting the value of Mayweather having an "undefeated" record thus far but that's not the issue.....40-0 is 40-0 no matter how you put it.

But the subjective part is where the questions begin to trickle.

Who is Shanes best win?

[jrosales13]

So Andy Koelle has a better resume then Amir Khan. After all he fought Paul Williams and Andre Ward. Going by Walt Liquors logic.

OK but let me use your same example and ask who exactly has Khan fought that you said wow that dude has zero chance in beating the insult of glass chin Khan?

Like I said to make it more clear now.... A lost to a guy who has great chance in beating you>A win against a guy who has zero chance in beating you....

[Frank Martin]

Resume = Overall record. Doesnt matter if is Win, Lose or Draw.

Great resume is determined by great wins. Doenst matter if you lose as long as it is an elite fighter. Basing resume on wins only is just plain ******. So you are saying Floyd is better than Duran coz Duran loses to the like of Pazienza and Joppy.

[jrosales13]

Who is Shanes best win?

The first Oscar fight.... Now who has Floyd fought that was better than that version of Oscar? Castillo? Corrales? Hatton? Were they better than that prime WW version of Oscar?

[B.U.R.N.E.R]

OK but let me use your same example and ask who exactly has Khan fought that you said wow that dude has zero chance in beating the insult of glass chin Khan?

Like I said to make it more clear now.... A lost to a guy who has great chance in beating you>A win against a guy who has zero chance in beating you....

This is not what we were arguing in this thread. Walt Liquor said that Shane has a bettre resume then Floyd because of Vernon and Winky. I reminded him that he LOST all 4 fights.

by his logic.

Oscar is has the greatest resume ever.

Jermain Taylor has a better resume then Pac.

Andy Koelle has a better resume then Amir Khan.

[B.U.R.N.E.R]

The first Oscar fight.... Now who has Floyd fought that was better than that version of Oscar? Castillo? Corrales? Hatton? Were they better than that prime WW version of Oscar?

Wait the fight where no one knows if Shane was roiding or not?

[B.U.R.N.E.R]

Resume = Overall record. Doesnt matter if is Win, Lose or Draw.

Great resume is determined by great wins. Doenst matter if you lose as long as it is an elite fighter. Basing resume on wins only is just plain ******. So you are saying Floyd is better than Duran coz Duran loses to the like of Pazienza and Joppy.

I like this game.

Oscar has a better resume then EVERYBODY.