If Pac and PBF both win their next fights, who ranks #1 P4P?

[HighFlyer]

Then they're like Octavius and Antoninus = there can only be one. No p4p king until they fight each other.

My personal opinion would be to give it to Floyd, since he's facing a bigger challenge in Mosley.

add this...an OLDER & SLOWER version of Sugar Shane Mosley.

[Left Banned Tua]

Floyd to number 1.

Beating Mosley is much more impressive than beating Clottey.

they don't go fight by fight , nimrod.

they go by the body of your recent work.

[phxmarlo]

they both got in the ring with the same guys in threre last fights except pac got in with a stone age cotto pbf would have one up on pac

[jrosales13]

Pac would still be ranked #1 IMO.

I think people put too much stock into P4P though.

Co-sign...

[BigStereotype]

Edwin Valero

[sncool1]

Floyd only become P4P #1 if he faces Pacquiao and wins.

[Rickety Cricket]

pacquiao will remain #1 until he loses

[flexxx145]

I would have to say Mayweather because Mosley is #3 on the list and Clottey is nowhere on the list. Basically Mosley > Clottey to simplify things. IF Manny was fighting PW and won I would become a fan for life though. Anybody saying a win over Mosley isn't better than a win over Clottey is biased or ignorant about boxing.

[tmen]

Definitely Manny Pacquiao...

I think Mayweather will onlu overtake himif he wins againts him or if Pac lost one of his matches...

[murmagic]

Its close but manny has to edge it because how he beat cotto,hatton,oscar and diaz and floyd has fought beat just maquez in that timeframe but i would have floyd as #1 WW because shane is #1 ww atm