TELL ME !! who is better, Malignaggi or Maidana?

[AIDS BOY]

Anyone who voted for Malignaggi is mentally insane.

Maidana would murder Malignaggi.


But I would love to see Khan vs Malignaggi cuz that would be massacre.

Khan would probably knock his ass out!

[Ryn0]

haha. lol so Maidana's resume is better then Malignaggi's?!?! haha

We'll there not as far apart as you think, Malignaggi has N'dou and Diaz on his record Diaz being his best win. With dominating losses to Hatton and Cotto and a close controvertial loss to Diaz.

Maidana has a close loss to Kotelnik VERY close, and a win over Ortiz. Malignaggi has a better resume but not by much since N'dou is worse that Ortiz and Diaz has lost 3 of his last 5 one by KO. Maidana would prove more to people about Khan that Malignaggi, I think Khan will comfortably beat Malignaggi infact i'm positive because of his style.

[IIG]

I can't even say that Maidana is world class, and there's no way he is better than Malignaggi. I'm in the minority that believe Khan would have knocked out Maidana, but the Malignaggi fight will be alot closer. I'm not even a Khan fan, but I think doubting him for the Prescott win is getting real old at this point. He got caught that night, but you need skill and power to get Khan out of there for the most part. I like the fight with Paulie, and I can see a 6-6 draw or a 7-5 victory for either guy.

[Sweet Jesus]

We'll there not as far apart as you think, Malignaggi has N'dou and Diaz on his record Diaz being his best win. With dominating losses to Hatton and Cotto and a close controvertial loss to Diaz.

Maidana has a close loss to Kotelnik VERY close, and a win over Ortiz. Malignaggi has a better resume but not by much since N'dou is worse that Ortiz and Diaz has lost 3 of his last 5 one by KO. Maidana would prove more to people about Khan that Malignaggi, I think Khan will comfortably beat Malignaggi infact i'm positive because of his style.

Yeah, you've never seen Cotto-Malignaggi.

[Dirk Diggler UK]

Paulie is a better overall fighter.

[ianntheman]

Malingaggi if the better boxer that a wrap! but on the other hand waaazz is so in love with Khan....you gay?

[Ryn0]

Yeah, you've never seen Cotto-Malignaggi.

Please, Malignaggi did well in the Cotto bout. But he was still brutally beaten up especially in the later rounds (From round 9 onwards Cotto swept those rounds and beat Maliganggi up)

At the start he was boxing well, but it wasn't close and Malignaggi took a LOT of punishment. It was cose through 8 but he was losing since he was cut in the first and knocked down in the second sure he gave a good account of himself ans showed boxing skills he still lost clearly.

[BetterCallSaul]

Mallignaggi is much better and would beat Maidana. Christ, Kotelnik beat Maidana.

Power - Maidana
Movement - Mallignaggi
Chin - Mallignaggi
Skills - Mallignaggi
Speed - Mallignaggi

Says it all really. Khan should fight Maidana because he is his mandatory, but I can live with Mallignaggi. A much more interesting 'boxing' match.

[Scott9945]

haha. lol so Maidana's resume is better then Malignaggi's?!?! haha

Who did Malignaggi ever beat that was nearly as dangerous as Ortiz? Lovemore N'Dou? Juan Diaz? Edner Cherry? Let me know when you have a legitimate answer...

[Number One]

its Malignaggi....