If both win who's p4p 1

[Dorian]

Depends on how they win but at the end of the day, a win is a win.

Manny Pacquiao should remain P4P king until he loses or Floyd beats him, which won'r happen for awhile..

[abdiel2k3]

No **** moron, everyone knows that. Fact is Floyd, the #3 guy, beating Shane, the #2 guy doesn't equal number one. The reason Floyd took over for RJJ was because there was no possibility of the 2 ever meeting in the ring. They were in completely different weight classes. Plus, RJJ losing a couple fights didn't help either. There was a void that Roy left and Floyd filled. P4P is all opinion. If Pac destroys Clottey and Floyd beats shane in a UD or SD, I don't see anything changing except the #2 and #3 spot.

clearlyyyy
ur unbiased
i mean look at your sig
lol

[gapo]

It has to be pac performing badly against clottey and mayweather knocking out mosley. I don't see both happening like that. I've never seen pacquiao in a boring fight just yet. I can't say the same thing to mayweather.

[BigStereotype]

Look, I think Margo is as awful as anyone after the Shane incident. But after the Cotto fight, he takes his gloves off immediately. Would you do that if you had cement in your gloves? Probably not. Not only that, someone grabs his hand and lifts it. There is no way they wouldn't have felt that plaster in his wraps. Bottomline is, he didn't cheat against Cotto. Cotto just got the **** kicked out of him. Of course there wasn't the same accumulation against Mosley - Mosley was beating the sense out of Margarito all night. It was a one-sided beatdown. Cotto was on the run all night and getting beat to a pulp. That's why his face was all ****ed up, not because of any plaster.

That being said, he still took a beating and it somewhat lessens the value of the win for Pacquiao. I say Manny is holding onto the top spot by the skin of his teeth - if he doesn't either KO Clottey or win a one-sided UD and Floyd outpoints Shane, then he gets the P4P title.

[ThunderWolf]

If mayweather and pacman both win do you think the rankings will change ?

would you change them ?

Pacquiao already won the fighter of the decade award, which seals his P4P-1 rating even if both wins.

Moreover, Mosley, if he loses this fight, could be rated as an old, washed up and past-prime fighter. This would not improve FLoyd`s rating much.

However, Floyd, as another newly crowned ww champ, would result in a world-wide clamor for a unification showdown with the Pacman to settle all titles once and for all.

[KRUEGER]

No pac is still the pfp #1

[1toTHADOME]

LOL
***in pac idiots
p4p belt is not won by beatin the guy
lol
if u remember for most the 90s roy jones was considered the p4p best
followed by floyd
so maybe i missed it when floyd beat roy
p4p is somethin obtained by beatin the best
and after these fights both wininng
floyd will have beat the better opposition
hed def take a step above pac

lol aright.. Roy Jones got knocked out twice and lost on a decision, which he was on a losing streak before Floyd took over p4p in 05. Floyd obviously was the best boxer even more over Tarver after what he did to Jones.

If they both win then.. it's STILLLLL THE BEST BOXER IN WORLLDDDDDDD MANNY! PACMAN! PACQUIIIIAAAOOOOOO just like Michael Buffer would.

[1toTHADOME]

even tho floyd is fighting the better fighter, DOES NOT make him the better fighter. if floyd wants the crown back, he's going to have beat the king.

[KRUEGER]

nope. Floyd must take the title from the p4p champ himself.

nice milf......

[gapo]

Look, I think Margo is as awful as anyone after the Shane incident. But after the Cotto fight, he takes his gloves off immediately. Would you do that if you had cement in your gloves? Probably not. Not only that, someone grabs his hand and lifts it. There is no way they wouldn't have felt that plaster in his wraps. Bottomline is, he didn't cheat against Cotto. Cotto just got the **** kicked out of him. Of course there wasn't the same accumulation against Mosley - Mosley was beating the sense out of Margarito all night. It was a one-sided beatdown. Cotto was on the run all night and getting beat to a pulp. That's why his face was all ****ed up, not because of any plaster.

That being said, he still took a beating and it somewhat lessens the value of the win for Pacquiao. I say Manny is holding onto the top spot by the skin of his teeth - if he doesn't either KO Clottey or win a one-sided UD and Floyd outpoints Shane, then he gets the P4P title.

Cotto was winning the early rounds. It wasn't like cotto slowed down after 3 or 4 round. He started showing all these bumps and swelling after seven. Clearly to me, the plaster was already hard. He did not have to hit cotto hard. He just had to touch him and blood gushingout of cotto. You know what,no need to even talk about it.We will never know. The bad thing for margo, he got caught.