Ring Magazine Results: "Mayweather vs. All-Time Welterweight Greats"

[jrosales13]

Jro I dont know why you act like EVERY ATG beats Floyds ass. Thats nuts bro. Floyd is one of the most skilled and talented fighters of ALL TIME.

That cant be argued.

I don't know you act like Floyd can any ATG WW ass or even come close to it... I don't know what any other ATG WW Floyd has beaten that can make you believe that?

I think Floyd at 130 can beat a lot of ATG fighters at 130, I think he can beat a lot of ATG at 135 even at 140... at 147 he can beat some but the ones at this list are awesome...IMO Gavilan, Armstrong, SRR, and Gavilan are 4 of the top 5 ATG WWs... With Jimmy McClarnin being the 5th guy... I don't know who Floyd has beat that are on these fighers level... If there is one please name? To say Floyd easily whoops Gavilan ass is laughable to me. But, that is your opinion and at the end of the day I respect it but I disagree...

All I know is that when it comes to fantasy fights Floyd is the G.O.A.T... I agree with Chups I am surprised he didn't win all of them... And, I am even more shocked that you Robinson and Leonard to BARELY edge out a decision over Floyd....

[-Reflexes-]

I don't know you act like Floyd can any ATG WW ass or even come close to it... I don't know what any other ATG WW Floyd has beaten that can make you believe that?

I think Floyd at 130 can beat a lot of ATG fighters at 130, I think he can beat a lot of ATG at 135 even at 140... at 147 he can beat some but the ones at this list are awesome...IMO Gavilan, Armstrong, SRR, and Gavilan are 4 of the top 5 ATG WWs... With Jimmy McClarnin being the 5th guy... I don't know who Floyd has beat that are on these fighers level... If there is one please name? To say Floyd easily whoops Gavilan ass is laughable to me. But, that is your opinion and at the end of the day I respect it but I disagree...

All I know is that when it comes to fantasy fights Floyd is the G.O.A.T... I agree with Chups I am surprised he didn't win all of them... And, I am even more shocked that you Robinson and Leonard to BARELY edge out a decision over Floyd....

Who has Gavilian beat thats as SKILLED , SMART, FAST, INSANE FOOTSPEED, ACCURATE, GREAT DEFENSIVELY, INSANE REFLEXES and TALENTED as Mayweather??

Goes both ways.

Its called Fantasy for a reason. You take the fighters and their styles and put them in the ring.

Im sorry Gavilan gets his ass beat.

Leonard and Robinson edge Floyd out.

Floyd at 147 STILL has ATG skill level. There isnt a fighter in history that you can put him in the ring with and say he has ZERO chance.

[Konstantin]

Just curious, what are you basing this on?

He's a huge welter. A terrific boxer. And for the style that Floyd has employed at WW (pot-shotting) tall rangy guys are more difficult to beat. He actually had a somewhat difficult time against DLH. Similar to Jones Tarver.

[jrosales13]

Who has Gavilian beat thats as SKILLED , SMART, FAST, INSANE FOOTSPEED, ACCURATE, GREAT DEFENSIVELY, INSANE REFLEXES and TALENTED as Mayweather??

Goes both ways.

Its called Fantasy for a reason. You take the fighters and their styles and put them in the ring.

Im sorry Gavilan gets his ass beat.

Leonard and Robinson edge Floyd out.

Floyd at 147 STILL has ATG skill level. There isnt a fighter in history that you can put him in the ring with and say he has ZERO chance.

OK Burner tell me why Leonard and SRR beat Floyd?

[-Reflexes-]

OK Burner tell me why Leonard and SRR beat Floyd?

I favor them for ONE reason and one reason only.

Everything Floyd did...they did better except defense. Hard to win against that.

Floyds defense, reflexes, handspeed and smarts keep it close.

[DonTaseMeBrah]

Floyd loses VERY CLOSE fights to Robinson and Leonard.

Beats everyone else.

(I heard Burley was a bad mutha****a but no footage of him exists to back it up)

burner, didnt you say you did a paper on charley burley?





& you benched 395 in 9th grade too huh?

[jrosales13]

I favor them for ONE reason and one reason only.

Everything Floyd did...they did better except defense. Hard to win against that.

Floyds defense, reflexes, handspeed and smarts keep it close.

Really now? Now I am just curious fuck this Floyd ****....

How do you see a fight with Leonard and Burley playing out?

What about a fight with Armstrong and Gavilan?

[thatnickuh]

That Hearns hits hard. Thats all they base it on. Most of these guys act like Floyd is Micky Ward or some ****.

Hed **** up Gavilian and REALLY **** up Armstrong.

Lose VERY CLOSE fights to Leonard and SRR.

How many times did Robinson fight at Welterweight? I wasn't aware that he fought that low. Regardless these comparisons are silly. Styles make fights, and athletes have gotten better over time. I don't even see how you compare a Mayweather with a Armstrong. Plus there's the size and age factors. Prime Mayweather isn't a Welterweight. Comparing a prime Leonard or Hearns against a prime Mayweather is a mismatch.

[-Reflexes-]

[/B]






burner, didnt you say you did a paper on charley burley?





& you benched 395 in 9th grade too huh?

Well **** me. I couldve SWORE that footage of him right there is NOT at WW.

I said I benched 300 in 9th grade. 395 is my max now.

[Evil Abed]

I noticed that SRL had a hard time trying to take out Floyd SR.

He probably wouldn't knockout PBF.

But I can see it going ether way.