A Floyd win over Moseley is better than ANY win on Pacs resume.

[BALLISTIC]

aside hatton and DLH pacmans face better fighters....

[The_Demon]

more shoulda,woulda,coulda from a floyd fan

how is it living up in fantasy land?

[mike19727]

A Mayweather win over Mosely would be most impressive. But if the fight happens, Mosley is the one who will win.

[piye]

I'm sorry the level of intelligence here is disturbing calling a professional fighter and an ATG by most people's standards a fraud is silly.

Pac nor Floyd is a 'Fraud' Pac is su****ious due to refusing a drug test and that is the only allegation I would throw about! Calling a fighter who has risen to the top of the sport a fraud is laughable!

Floyd has a great Resume! Pac in my opinion has a slightly better Resume!

Barrera, Morales, JMM, Oscar, Hatton, Cotto is amazing!

But so is Corrales, Castillo, Zab, Oscar, Hatton and JMM! now if Floyd beats Shane then he has a better single win than any of Pacs Single wins and arguable a better resume!

[tesla_power]

I'm sorry the level of intelligence here is disturbing calling a professional fighter and an ATG by most people's standards a fraud is silly.

Pac nor Floyd is a 'Fraud' Pac is su****ious due to refusing a drug test and that is the only allegation I would throw about! Calling a fighter who has risen to the top of the sport a fraud is laughable!

Floyd has a great Resume! Pac in my opinion has a slightly better Resume!

Barrera, Morales, JMM, Oscar, Hatton, Cotto is amazing!

But so is Corrales, Castillo, Zab, Oscar, Hatton and JMM! now if Floyd beats Shane then he has a better single win than any of Pacs Single wins and arguable a better resume!

The JMM win for Floyd is just a name. IMO, jmm should not be included in his best wins. Unlike pac, because the field is level at that point. If pac ever fights Jmm at 147, then it should not be credited as well.

[k1t3]

Including Pacquiao's win against the Mexican greats Morales, Barrera and Marquez?

[piye]

The JMM win for Floyd is just a name. IMO, jmm should not be included in his best wins. Unlike pac, because the field is level at that point. If pac ever fights Jmm at 147, then it should not be credited as well.

OK but if we are serious, and that fight should not be counted neither should the DelaHoya fight for Pac as that guy was a dehydrated Zombie. So in reality when the fanboy non sense is put away both Pac and May have a similar Resume.

[tesla_power]

OK but if we are serious, and that fight should not be counted neither should the DelaHoya fight for Pac as that guy was a dehydrated Zombie. So in reality when the fanboy non sense is put away both Pac and May have a similar Resume.

Well, you could always say that was a dehydrated Oscar. But that is hindsight.
Pac-Oscar = 4 is to 1 in favor of Oscar
Pbf-Jmm = 4 is to 1 in favor of Pbf

Other than heart, what advantages did you give Jmm pre fight?
height, reach, power, speed, age all went to Pbf. Boxing skill also but it can be debated. Inteligence can be debated. Skills can be debated. Experience can be debated. What else? Possibly cornermen. Any others you could think of?

[piye]

Well, you could always say that was a dehydrated Oscar. But that is hindsight.
Pac-Oscar = 4 is to 1 in favor of Oscar
Pbf-Jmm = 4 is to 1 in favor of Pbf

Other than heart, what advantages did you give Jmm pre fight?
height, reach, power, speed, age all went to Pbf. Boxing skill also but it can be debated. Inteligence can be debated. Skills can be debated. Experience can be debated. What else? Possibly cornermen. Any others you could think of?

True but hindsight is not always a bad thing! we saw a Dehydrated Oscar barely move while Pac smashed him in the face repeatedly. That fight doesn't count for much! who out of the top fighters wouldn't have beaten that Oscar?

But this is besides the point Fact is both Mayweather and Pac have amazing resumes but there is not much between them! with Pac slightly edging it! if Floyd beats Moseley He has a better win than any of Pac's.

[KoPill]

OK but if we are serious, and that fight should not be counted neither should the DelaHoya fight for Pac as that guy was a dehydrated Zombie. So in reality when the fanboy non sense is put away both Pac and May have a similar Resume.

Disagree with that. That was Oscar himself cherry picking a smaller man, that he thought he could have his way with. Oscar could have easily fought Antonio Margarito, but instead decided to pick on the little man. Manny Pacquiao had to move up 2 weight classes, and hope that his skills carried up with him. Which I have to give a lot credit to Ariza because he did a good job of bringing Manny up from LW, to WW, without Manny losing any of his strengths. If done wrong that could have been disastrous. As was with the case with Oscar. Oscar IMO bit off more then he could chew. #1 he hasn't made WW, since back when he fought Gatti, in 01. #2 his nutritionist did a *** up job with managing his weight and nutrition. #3 yeah he was probably dehydrated, but you can't blame Manny for that. He did what he had to do, which was to come in at the best shape that he could to win the fight.