Would Calzaghe have beaten Jones in his prime?

[Grimmer]

I'm a big Calzaghe fan.

But no. RJJ was something special in his prime.

[Mojita]

No, I don't think Prime for Prime Joe can beat Roy.

Roy had his reflexes, crazy speed and of course his power in his prime.

I believe he would have slowed Joe's work rate with his fast punches that would have had Joe second guessing and from there on out Roy could win a decision. It'd probably be a competitive fight but I just don't think prime for prime Joe was never on his level and never will be.

[baracuda]

definitely yes......

[razor.thin]

maybe, maybe not.

[The Surgeon]

About as likely as me beating Usain Bolt in a 100m sprint!

[shonuff488]

Get the hell outta here. Enzo would of had to throw in the towel just like Clinton Woods corner did. Roy in his prime couldn't be beat.

[Johnny Rebel]

Calzaghe beats Jones at any point of their respective HOF careers!

[Pugilistic™]

In my opinion, no.

[Joe's left hook]

I tend not to like whiteboys, but I don't mind Joe Calzaghe.

Not many guys have been World Champion for well over a decade and retired undefeated. Also, for him to unify his division, then go and win a World title at Light-Heavyweight against the great Bernard Hopkins (long before Bernard destroyed Kelly Pavlik) is kinda impressive.

I'm a go for the Brit.