Toney...What could have been!!

[Shaolin Bushido]

Toney's special...even with a fat-ass, physique doesn't win fights, clean overhand right countershots will win you 4 world championships though....

Toney is Canastosa-bound, I'd put him in the top 20 p4p all-time, 2-3 more big wins (Vitali, Byrd) would make him top-10 all time and one of the top 3-4 of our generation IMO

You're joking, right? Toney will get in based on his place as one of the few middles to win the heavyweight championship but he won't be discussed much by anyone listing their all-timers. He's a footnote right now, though I agree he could have been a whole lot more significant if he'd managed to be more disciplined, focussed, and goal oriented.

Maybe he could change that if he somehow ran the table on the other contenders but that's very unlikely.