WTF?! How come BoxRec rates Maidana higher than Khan?!!?

[Liar]

and once again this thread has been hijacked by Amir khan-Haters. no need to comment here anymore.

How am I hating? I just think Maidana is the better fighter and done more. Just because I go against you, doesn't mean I am hating

[wXh..]

What is the wXh light welter weight rating? I rate Khan above Maidana but I can see why BoxRec don't see it that way.

1. Bradley
2. Amir Khan

3. Malignaggi
4. Alexander
5. Urango
6. Maidana
7. Campbell
8. Holt
9. Kotelnik
10. Ortiz

[daggum]

1. Bradley
2. Amir Khan

3. Malignaggi
4. Alexander
5. Urango
6. Maidana
7. Campbell
8. Holt
9. Kotelnik
10. Ortiz

didn't khan beat the worst champion in boxing?(according to himself) so this magically propels him above all the other champs and contenders?

[Liar]

1. Bradley
2. Amir Khan

3. Malignaggi
4. Alexander
5. Urango
6. Maidana
7. Campbell
8. Holt
9. Kotelnik
10. Ortiz

Where is Ricky Hatton?

[gingeralbino]

1. Bradley
2. Amir Khan

3. Malignaggi
4. Alexander
5. Urango
6. Maidana
7. Campbell
8. Holt
9. Kotelnik
10. Ortiz

I notice how u left Pac and Hatton of that list. Pac is the champ, and could well be fighting at 140 in his next fight against Paulie, and Hatton hasnt retired. Both rank above Khan. And Khan may well be better than the rest of your top 10 but he hasnt proved it yet. Paulie and maybe Alexander should be above him.
Hopefully Khan fights 3 times in 2010 against top 10 140lbers so we can see if he live up to his potential.

My guess is he'll fight and beat Maidana, batter Paulie, then fight Bradley at the end of 2010. Then we'll no longer have to guess how good he is, we'll know one way or another. Unless Frank Warren has any say in who he fights, then he'll fight Paulie and 2 bums

[daggum]

I notice how u left Pac and Hatton of that list. Pac is the champ, and could well be fighting at 140 in his next fight against Paulie, and Hatton hasnt retired. Both rank above Khan. And Khan may well be better than the rest of your top 10 but he hasnt proved it yet. Paulie and maybe Alexander should be above him.
Hopefully Khan fights 3 times in 2010 against top 10 140lbers so we can see if he live up to his potential.

My guess is he'll fight and beat Maidana, batter Paulie, then fight Bradley at the end of 2010. Then we'll no longer have to guess how good he is, we'll know one way or another. Unless Frank Warren has any say in who he fights, then he'll fight Paulie and 2 bums

are you mental? he will probably fight david diaz, gavin rees and salita in a rematch after he claws his way back to mandatory with some more bum fights.

[gingeralbino]

are you mental? he will probably fight david diaz, gavin rees and salita in a rematch after he claws his way back to mandatory with some more bum fights.

the 2nd part of the paragraph covered what would hapen if Warren had any say. I think Khan would fight anyone (except Pac). He thinks he's the dogs balls and good enough to beat everyone.
Was probably getting carried away with the Bradley fight in fairness, more hope than expectation......

[Syf]

and once again this thread has been hijacked by Amir khan-Haters. no need to comment here anymore.

What did you expect? Everyone to fall all over themselves agreeing with you?


There are some people that don't worship at Khan's feet, you know. He is too green still to be considered #2

[daggum]

the 2nd part of the paragraph covered what would hapen if Warren had any say. I think Khan would fight anyone (except Pac). He thinks he's the dogs balls and good enough to beat everyone.
Was probably getting carried away with the Bradley fight in fairness, more hope than expectation......

khan doesn't have to fight bradley anyway he can just use that pathetic mayweather excuse "he's not a big draw"

[Squirrel]

I think Miadana is under-rated: his only loss is a CLOSE split decision to Kotelnik (in Germany, no less), and he's shown great determination in fights were he's been dropped many times, to come back and win.

Not exactly the next Ali but he's young and determined.