Historical Middleweight Tournament

[andrewcuff]

Following on from the Hagler/Hopkins and "Anti-Pac/May" threads...

Using the format of the current Super Six, who wins out of a historial version featuring:

Marvin Hagler,
Bernard Hopkins,
Carlos Monzon,
James Toney,
Mike McCallum,
Roy Jones Jr

Describe how each fight plays out and ultimately who wins the tournament?

The stages are as follows:

Stage 1:
Hagler vs Hopkins
McCallum vs Jones
Toney vs Monzon

Stage 2:
Monzon vs Jones
McCallum vs Hopkins
Toney vs Hagler

Stage 3:
Hagler vs Jones
McCallum vs Monzon
Hopkins vs Toney

Assume these fighters are all in their prime, with no weight issues etc.

[Rabbit ♠]

This will be good. I have to think hard because I'm always biased towards RJJ lol

[LEFTYGUNZZ]

Following on from the Hagler/Hopkins and "Anti-Pac/May" threads...

Using the format of the current Super Six, who wins out of a historial version featuring:

Marvin Hagler,
Bernard Hopkins,
Carlos Monzon,
James Toney,
Mike McCallum,
Roy Jones Jr

Describe how each fight plays out and ultimately who wins the tournament?

Hard to tell depends on how the first round is laid out....Lefty

[dans]

Following on from the Hagler/Hopkins and "Anti-Pac/May" threads...

Using the format of the current Super Six, who wins out of a historial version featuring:

Marvin Hagler,
Bernard Hopkins,
Carlos Monzon,
James Toney,
Mike McCallum,
Roy Jones Jr

Describe how each fight plays out and ultimately who wins the tournament?

I would pick Hagler to win it all.

Hopkins could beat Hagler, but I think Hagler has the edge overall.

If I had to guess, the final would be Roy Jones vs. Hagler.

[boxerca]

Hagler and Jones would most likely be in the finals and then I would have to pick Jones by decision.

[murmagic]

i would say hagler also, in the final with rrj if all were at there primes

[COACH WEBB]

WOW!!!!!!!

I like Hagler-Jones in the final.

[Rabbit ♠]

Damn I want to say Jones would beat Hagler in the final but in my heart I just know Hagler would win....

[dans]

I wouldln't bet against Monzon though. That guy was nearly unbeatable in his prime.

After losing for the 3rd time in 1964, Monzon never lost until his last fight in 1977.

[Joey Giardello]

Carlos monzon