Best southpaw fighter ever?

[Pacdbest]

Whitaker defense was better just look at Whitaker-Chavez and Floyd-Castillo. I don't know where you rank Whitaker or Floyd all time. But, IMO Whitaker is like top 15. While Floyd is outside my top 50.

As I told you I dont care where will Floyd or Whitaker will be rated!! All I know is they will be below Pac!!!

[Pacdbest]

Naw Shadows said it was on the countdown of Mosley-Cotto.

And, if that is your opinion fine. I think you are wrong but whatever. But, I just didn't get why use Sugar to prove a point. When the man says off the wall ****.

Next time don't give me second hand news!!!

Sugar has a Resume of writing for years on Various Boxing Publications. I value more his writings & Opinion than a little fan wagoner like you!!!

[jrosales13]

As I told you I dont care where will Floyd or Whitaker will be rated!! All I know is they will be below Pac!!!

IMO Pac has to beat both Floyd and Shane to be rated higher than Whitaker.

[Pacdbest]

IMO Pac has to beat both Floyd and Shane to be rated higher than Whitaker.

Pac beats those 2 & Pac will replace SRR at #1!!!

[bojangles1987]

I'd say Whitaker for now, but wouldn't argue with those that say Pac. I love Hagler, but he fought orthodox often too so he isn't quite a true southpaw. The hard part is leaving out your opinion on who would win between Pac and Whitaker, and just going by their careers.

[The_Demon]

whitaker imo

pac could retire as the best southpaw ever though,depending on how things go

have too mention hagler aswel,who could fight orthodox also,but was truly an all round great fighter

[ghettocelebrity]

Bert sugar already said it's Pac!

**** Bet Sugar! imo it's sweet pea.

[#1Assassin]

whitaker followed by hagler, those two are in a class of their own. then theres guys like winky wright, pacquiao, michael moorer, naseem hamed etc. tarver was better than he gets credit for too, and dawson is a future ATG.

[djtmal]

tie between whitaker and hagler...contrasting styles makes it a tossup...

[CharlieGarbs]

Marvin Hagler.