If Joan Guzman beats Ali Funeka tonight, he should enter the top 10 P4P

[Zocalo]

No way would be top 10 with a win over Funeka

You need to post something illogical for it to go thru some of the obtuse plantain fanboys...

[Dondi33O]

We shouldn't compare Cotto to Guzman, no disrespect but Guzman is more well rounded, MUCH better defense, more accurate, better boxer/ counter puncher, can fight going backwards/ against the ropes, doesn't fold under pressure.

Yes he is, but I have non pros on my block that never fought anyone that are also "well rounded". So what?
They sit on benches talking about, Would of, could of, My people got my back, and back in da days I beat.... and they have that in common with Guzman. They are nothing just like Guzman.
The sad thing is YOU KNOW damn well he isnt acknowledged as all that and even with a win he wont be. He got a long way to go.

[Lokotron]

We shouldn't compare Cotto to Guzman, no disrespect but Guzman is more well rounded, MUCH better defense, more accurate, better boxer/ counter puncher, can fight going backwards/ against the ropes, doesn't fold under pressure and I need not mention hand speed/ foot speed.

You forgot to mention how Cotto runs at the end of every fight and has stamina problems.

[Heru]

We shouldn't compare Cotto to Guzman, no disrespect but Guzman is more well rounded, MUCH better defense, more accurate, better boxer/ counter puncher, can fight going backwards/ against the ropes, doesn't fold under pressure.

Real talk.

They would never admit a Dominican is greater or that he's better than a Rican at anything :****you:. It' nothing though, the truth will be the truth whether they admit it or not.

[boxing2106]

ofcource he shouldnt be p4p def not.. but if he wins he sure proved something... cuz its a fight where it presents a challenge nd were willing to see if he overcomes it

[Lokotron]

Once Again

Cotto is shouldn't be a P4P fighter for the obvious reasons:
1.He was losing to Judah up until the lowblow.
2.He had a close fight with SSM(Wich I thought SSM won)
3.He got dismantled by Margarito(Plaster or No plaster im going by what is there as of now.
4.He Ducked Paul Williams and waited for him to vacate his title to fight for his WBO.
5.He fought Michael Jennings a Nobody.
6.He actually lost to Clottey, but they robbed him
7.Pacquiao TKO'ed him.

[Zocalo]

hell no not at all. i went into a red k this so and so poster and clowned them for being so serious about a little rectangular .1 millimeter space. just that chups is my homie.

he beat verno for an INTERIM-belt.

Verno was the IBF champ when he faced Williams, but was forced to drop it to get a money fight on HBO vs Williams but don't let that plantain up your ass get in the way with something logical.

[Zarco]

Once Again

Cotto is shouldn't be a P4P fighter for the obvious reasons:
1.He was losing to Judah up until the lowblow.
2.He had a close fight with SSM(Wich I thought SSM won)
3.He got dismantled by Margarito(Plaster or No plaster im going by what is there as of now.
4.He Ducked Paul Williams and waited for him to vacate his title to fight for his WBO.
5.He fought Michael Jennings a Nobody.
6.He actually lost to Clottey, but they robbed him
7.Pacquiao TKO'ed him.

i actually agree with that. its crazy how after he got brutalized by margarito, he stayed in the top 10, he then beats a bum for a vacant belt, receives a puerto rican parade gift decision against clottey, gets brutalized by pacquiao, and is still in the p4p list.

Verno was the IBF champ when he faced Williams, but was forced to drop it to get a money fight on HBO vs Williams but don't let that plantain up your ass get in the way with something logical.

and juan manuel marquez has 2 wins over paquiao...

it dont matter if verno was the champion point is he was an ex champ when he fought williams.

[Heru]

guzman is fighting the guys no one wants to fight like humberto soto and ali funeka. we can't all be p4p number 2 for fighting guys moving up 2 weightclasses.

GTFOH with that pro Dominican ****. Don't ever post truth in here .

[Dondi33O]

Cotto is shouldn't be a P4P fighter for the obvious reasons:
1.He was losing to Judah up until the lowblow.
2.He had a close fight with SSM(Wich I thought SSM won)
3.He got dismantled by Margarito(Plaster or No plaster im going by what is there as of now.
4.He Ducked Paul Williams and waited for him to vacate his title to fight for his WBO.
5.He fought Michael Jennings a Nobody.
6.He actually lost to Clottey, but they robbed him
7.Pacquiao TKO'ed him.

Like I said...Guzmans lovers will and cannot change.
1.that Cotto is still acknowledged on the P4p list
2. Guzman is not on the P4p list
3. Even with a win Guzman wont be acknowledged on the P4P list.
4. Good chance he might lose tonight.
5. Most people dont even like Guzman.
6. Many people came to this thread thinking it was a Joke thread.
7. Nate beat Funeka whether Guzman fans like it or not.
8. Over half the posters on here dont agree with Guzman being p4P.
Might I suggest you team up with(since he brought them into this) kevin the dominican and get the trinitarios to jump and beat down the people who make the p4p list and.....
9. still he wont be acknowledged on the P4P list.