So Manny is still higher than Floyd even if??

[talip bin osman]

You're confusing skill with accomplishment, my brother.

On a pure skill level ; there's no question that Floyd mayweather Jr. is far beyond Manny Pacquiao on the field of skill level.

But on an accomplishment level ; Manny is ranking above Floyd, currently. In everybody's mind.

Skill doesn't determine your legacy ; accomplishments do.

Bennie Briscoe was one of the most skilled Middleweights of All Time, in my opinion. But he never won a World title.

Same goes with Packey McFarland at Lightweight.

great post as usual bringer sir...

and skills are really subjective... boxing is not diving or gymnastics...

[mannyman]

Pac has beaten JMM....Barerra, Morales, Cotto, Oscar and Hatton.

Floyd has beaten JMM, Judah, Hernandez, Corralles, Castillo, Oscar, and Hatton, and then Pacman.


Floyd would be greater.

Floyd kayod Hatton - Pacquiao annihilated him
Floyd SDd DLH - Pacquiao annihilated him (before you mention 'weight-drained' Pac was a heavy underdog)
Floyd wouldn't fight Cotto - Pacquiao annihilated him
Pac fought Marquez at his optimum weight and fought in two competitive and exciting fights - MM bullied him

BTW way MMs a great fighter but ppl gota giv Pac his props

[ßringer]

Dont try to act like Pacs win over Oscar was anything significant. It was just another name/ There was never any threat there.

Same with a shot Morales ( 3rd fght).......Diaz......Larios.

See what I did there.

Floyd's win over Oscar > Manny's win over Oscar

Manny's win over Hatton > Floyd's win over Hatton

Those two cancel one another out.

That leaves Manny with MarcoX2, Erik X2, Juan Manuel X2, and Cotto.

And Floyd with CastilloX2, Corrales, Hernandez, and a blown up Marquez.

I'd say Barrera and Morales are equal to Corrales and Castillo, in terms of risk and reward.

Manny definitely fought a much more game Juan manuel Marquez than Floyd did by fighting him at Welterweight.

That leaves Hernandez vs. Cotto.

Manny's accomplishments are beating Floyd's right now bro, face it.

7 titles in 7 weight divisions says it all.

[ßringer]

great post as usual bringer sir...

and skills are really subjective... boxing is not diving or gymnastics...

Indeed.

Especially the bolded.

Solid point, my man.

[Frank Martin]

Floyd cannot take away what Pac has accomplished.

[ShoguNinja]

Manniy is a Champ, Floyd is Joke! Until he fights and beat Mosley and Manny... He will never have a Legacy greater than Manny.

[Burner]

Floyd's win over Oscar > Manny's win over Oscar

Manny's win over Hatton > Floyd's win over Hatton

Those two cancel one another out.

That leaves Manny with MarcoX2, Erik X2, Juan Manuel X2, and Cotto.

And Floyd with CastilloX2, Corrales, Hernandez, and a blown up Marquez.

I'd say Barrera and Morales are equal to Corrales and Castillo, in terms of risk and reward.

Manny definitely fought a much more game Juan manuel Marquez than Floyd did by fighting him at Welterweight.
That leaves Hernandez vs. Cotto.

Manny's accomplishments are beating Floyd's right now bro, face it.

7 titles in 7 weight divisions says it all.

Mayweather definitely fought a much more game Oscar De LeHoya and Ricky Hatton no???

[Burner]

Indeed.

Especially the bolded.

Solid point, my man.

It doesnt matter if Pac fought apes his whole career it doesnt mean a damn thing when Floyd Mayweather Jr. is starring at you across the ring....most people Floyd fight realize right there that there in aginst a ukking defensive machine who fights PERFECTLY.....Mayweather reminds me of the last level bosses in the fighting video games...lol.

[REMOVED SHARK 97]

Manny beating Floyd would push him top 5 ATG for me.

[h2k]

even if floyd beats manny?

manny has 5 belts in 5 weight classes

floyd has 6 belts in 5 weight classes

is this pure hate keeping floyd from being ranked higher in your eyes if he were to beat manny when they fight?

I know you're a floyd hater you're always making floyd look bad. Please stop insulting mayweather for telling lies.