If Pacquiao beats Cotto, will you consider him the fighter of the decade?

[big_james10]

Mayweather never gives rematches. The fact that he did, shows he knew he lost and wanted to come back and prove something.

I had Castillo up 8-4.

Who did he NEED to give a rematch to other than Castillo: Diego Corrales (KO in 10 after five knockdowns); Angel Manfredy (KO in 2); Genaro Hernandez (KO in 8); Arturo Gatto (KO in 6); Hatton (KO in 10); Judah (lost the last 8 rounds convincingly and woudl have been KOd if not for a low blow); Carlos Baldomir (who lost all 12 rounds). Of course you had Castillo up 8-4. You hate Mayweather. You didn't mention the second fight. Did you score the second fight 8-4 for Castillo also? even though Mayweather won 10 out of the 12 rounds?

The person who deserved a rematch was Juan Manuel Marquez after the second Pac fight. Unfortunately, Pac refused to give it to him. Instead he chose to fight world-beater David Diaz. Not to fret, though. Pac will fight Marquez next, not because he wants to, but because Arum willl not expose Pac to a Mayweather ass-whipping.

[chinoy]

Hahaha.....Mayweather would not even fight Cotto, Mosley or P will....all are in PBF's weight division....

PBF could have waited a DAY to challenge Pac but he announced he will be fighting a boxer 2 divisions LOWER.....

what a delusional PBF nuthugger

He will be fighter of the year. If he wants to be fighter of the decade, he will have to fight and beat Mayweather and he won't do that. Bob Arum has already decided that Pac's next fight will be against Juan Manuel Marquez. He won't even try a SERIOUS negotiation for a Mayweather fight. However, he will claim that it couldn't be made and will make the Marquez fight. Then, all the clowns on this site will claim that Mayweather priced himself out when the truth is, Arum never had any intention of putting Pac in the ring with Mayweather in his next fight.

[daggum]

Who did he NEED to give a rematch to other than Castillo: Diego Corrales (KO in 10 after five knockdowns); Angel Manfredy (KO in 2); Genaro Hernandez (KO in 8); Arturo Gatto (KO in 6); Hatton (KO in 10); Judah (lost the last 8 rounds convincingly and woudl have been KOd if not for a low blow); Carlos Baldomir (who lost all 12 rounds). Of course you had Castillo up 8-4. You hate Mayweather. You didn't mention the second fight. Did you score the second fight 8-4 for Castillo also? even though Mayweather won 10 out of the 12 rounds?

The person who deserved a rematch was Juan Manuel Marquez after the second Pac fight. Unfortunately, Pac refused to give it to him. Instead he chose to fight world-beater David Diaz. Not to fret, though. Pac will fight Marquez next, not because he wants to, but because Arum willl not expose Pac to a Mayweather ass-whipping.

yea that makes you look like a reasonable poster........

[jrosales13]

Pac hands down FOTD even if he losses to Cotto. Pac is still FOTD. I think Floyd sould be second. Floyd resume after 2003 is nothing special. And, Hopkins third.

[MANGLER]

I'd accept him as fighter of the decade if he beats Cotto.

[zeidrich]

manny is already the Fighter of the decade even if he lose to cotto now

[Bobby_Manila]

Pac hands down FOTD even if he losses to Cotto. Pac is still FOTD. I think Floyd sould be second. Floyd resume after 2003 is nothing special. And, Hopkins third.

Hopkins? Hopkins is great. A very smart fighter. Beat the living **** out of Pavlik.

But his wins against De la Hoya and Tito... let's say he won them with his intelligence. He suckered those two into fighting him at his weight. They had no business in that ring.

So he gets a third place as fighter of the decade by beating Tarver, Winky and Pavlik, by losing a close fight against Calz and losing two decisions against Taylor. I don't know...