Who deserved the win? (haye v valuev)

[sjomcik]

Of course Haye

[catalinul]

Haye.

You got an agenda if you think Valuev won.

[The_Visitation]

Haye.. just. Valuev was piss-poor for 12 rounds, Haye was only piss-poor for the first 11.

[Stab Judah]

Haye won I didn't even see it as close but I also didn't think that Haye "took the title" so i thought Val might get the decision.


Haye was fighting more like he was the champ rather than the challenger.

[Jambo boy]

Haye will destroy both Kilts.

At once.

[street bully]

Had it 6-6, didn't think Haye did enough.

[mathed]

cleaner and harder punches and stunned valuev
Haye, ugly fight but how do you expect to fight a 7 foot monster
boxing fans should rejoyce that we wont have to see valuev in another fight

Right, what was he supposed to do? Stand in front of the guy and slug it out and hope for the best at 100lbs lighter and a foot shorter?

[Doctor_Tenma]

Haye clearly won.

[-Boxzilla-]

fact of the matter is it coulda gone either way casue valuev was way too slow and haye was way to tentative ... the fact that haye won that kinda decision in germany is a miracle.

[Mr. Philadel]

See the british commentators were very negative of Haye but I dont think Valuev landed one good punch, Haye landed probably 8 or 9.

boring fight but i guess thats all you can do against the big guy, Haye also clearly wobbled him in the 12th when he started using that injured hand.

ironic......the German commentators were huggin' Haye's nuts all night......they were even upset at the 114-114 score......they said Haye was CLEARLY the better boxer!!