List your Top 5 Welterweights the last 5 years

[Iceta]

Paul Williams would be at the top of the list if everybody else listed in most people's top five would have the balls to fight him.

[WhoreUs]

You're absolutely right about Cotto. Huge brain fart there. I have Cotto as the #1 welter. But I'd put Shane over Tony. He just beat his a** something awful. Impressive win over Collazo, even Estrada who at one point was a somewhat decent fighter. I think Margarito's secondary wins are better than Shane's but when I factor in what Shane did to him...I just can't.

he was top 10 at one point at 147.

he beat a few undefeated prospects on his way up.

[WhoreUs]

Paul Williams would be at the top of the list if everybody else listed in most people's top five would have the balls to fight him.

margo did.

[WhoreUs]

In all honesty, I think Floyd is on most peoples lists because they recognise his talent but his resume over the last 5 years pales in comparison to the other welterweights on the list.

lies.

mayweather p4p #1!

[Sammy2g3]

1. Miguel Cotto
2. Floyd Mayweather
3. Paul Williams
4. Antonio Margarito
5. Shane Mosley

[fightfan_79]

Since 2005 , 147 has been laden with talent and have had some good to very good fighters.

Fighters like Floyd Mayweather Jr. , Shane Mosley , Paul Williams , Antonio Margarito , Joshua Clottey , Miguel Cotto , Luis Collazo , Cory Spinks , Andre Berto , etc.

List who you think were the best 5 fighters of the division since 2005.

Based on talent:
1- Floyd
2- Shane
3- Cotto
4- Judah
5- Berto

Honerable Mention: Kermit Cintron, Paul Williams

Based on Activity:
1- Shane
2- Cotto
3- Margarito
4- P-Will
5- Clottey

Honerable Mention: Kermit Cintron, Andre Berto

Cory Spinks was in the WW division until '04...moved to JrMW in '05...

[Uturn]

5. Hitman Hatton

[Bushbaby]

Cotto
Mosley
The Punisher
floyd
Clottey
In the last 5 years Cotto edges Mosley slightly but if u said at welterweight period,Mosley would be #1,because he has prime Oscar & Forrest on his resume as well!!Also I didn't include Margarito in my list because of the doubts about his gloves!!

[Animalistic 5.0]

1. Miguel Cotto
2. Shane Mosley
3. Antonio Margarito*
4. Paul Williams
5. Floyd Mayweather Jr


* Whole career in question because of his cheating. Clottey should be in his spot.

[WhoreUs]

Based on talent:
1- Floyd
2- Shane
3- Cotto
4- Judah
5- Berto

Honerable Mention: Kermit Cintron, Paul Williams

Based on Activity:
1- Shane
2- Cotto
3- Margarito
4- P-Will
5- Clottey

Honerable Mention: Kermit Cintron, Andre Berto

Cory Spinks was in the WW division until '04...moved to JrMW in '05...

i thought cory fought zab in 2005?