Who was your first favorite fighter?

[Fox McCloud]

I had Oscar loosing all those fights...

That is very disturbing...

Oscar clearly beat Mosley in the rematch and whipped Trinidad into shape early enough that Trinidad can't win without a knockdown/out IMO.

He obviously lost to Sturm, I thought it was fairly clear that he lost to Quartey, and the Whitaker fight is a toss-up.

[Heru]

While we are at it, who did your scorecard indicate in... De La Hoya vs.

Whitaker
Trinidad
Mosley I
Mosley II
Sturm
Mayweather

Need to go back and watch the fights, but I've posted a couple before that I remember:

De La Hoya

114-113 Quartey
116-112 Trinidad
115-113 Mosley II
113-115 Mayweather

[Fox McCloud]

Need to go back and watch the fights, but I've posted a couple before that I remember:

De La Hoya

114-113 Quartey
116-112 Trinidad
115-113 Mosley II
113-115 Mayweather

It's all good... Mosley I and Sturm were pretty clear losses for Oscar IMO... the clearest of the group, other than Mayweather.

[RockyB]

Iron Mike Tyson. The baddest man on the planet!

[Heru]

From what I remember, I had Oscar sweeping the first 4 against Quartey, Ike pretty much taking over except for one round in between and Oscar getting a 10-8 in the 12th. I remember scoring the round where they traded kds 10-9.

He swept all but 1 round of the first 9 against Trinidad.

Can't remember a lot about the second Mosley fight.

In the Mayweather fight they traded rounds in the first half, probably 4-2 for Oscar and 5-1 for Mayweather the second half.

[Heru]

It's all good... Mosley I and Sturm were pretty clear losses for Oscar IMO... the clearest of the group, other than Mayweather.

Yeah, I'm gonna watch and rescore a couple of these fights and leave some notes in the close rounds for some of these debates.

[jrosales13]

That is very disturbing...

Oscar clearly beat Mosley in the rematch and whipped Trinidad into shape early enough that Trinidad can't win without a knockdown/out IMO.

He obviously lost to Sturm, I thought it was fairly clear that he lost to Quartey, and the Whitaker fight is a toss-up.

Well I didn't see Quartey in the list. I thought Oscar won that by one point.

I thought in the Mosley rematch. Shane landed the more significant punches. I thought Oscar only landing pitty pat flurriess. I thought Shane won 7rds.

I thought Sturm beat him clearly.

I thought Shane won the first fight clearly.

I thought Whitaker won

I thought Floyd clearly won 8rds

The Tito-Oscar fight. I had Tito winning rds 1,4,5,9,10,11, and 12. I had Oscar winning rds 2,3,6,7,8, That leaves 7rd-5 (115-113) in favor of Tito. I thought rds 1 and 5 were swing rounds that could of gone either way though.

[Kevin Jesus]

RJJ, and still is.

[MaD RoBoT]

Iron Mike followed by Sugar Ray Leonard

[HeartAttack]

Man I'm in the minority here. But I was a big fan of Shannon Briggs when I was younger. He headlined the first show I ever went to, and turned out he headlined the first show that I ever covered as a writer too. Briggs fell out fairly fast and I moved on, but we're not always proud of our "first time" but we're fond of it. So I stand by good Ol' Briggsy years later.