If Cotto beats Pac...

[rao007]

No. Pacquiao is basically a visitor at 147. Beating a guy who's already smaller than you doesn't make you p4p. What logic is that?

[Chunk..]

No. Ring magazine's P4P list is hooky and flawed. They'll probably make Mosley #1 and keep Floyd at #2 so GBP can get the fight they want!

[Freddy Krueger]

He should be ranked above Mayweather, does Mayweather automatically get to be pfp number 2 after having Marquez move up 2 weight classes to fight him?

And also the fact that Mayweather has been retired for 2 years while other fighters have been working their asses off in the ring for the past 2 years like Mosley and Cotto.

[Ri-Coqui]

He probably should be, but it wont happen. Tito Trinidad was undefeated and got a win over Oscar De La Hoya the number 1 P4P fighter at the time, but yet he didn't get ranked number 1. He was fighting tough and top fighters and was undefeated while others who fought no name fighters took that position. It was like if they ranked Paul Williams number one despite not beating any elite fighter. P4P rankings are a joke.

[Chunk..]

He should be ranked above Mayweather, does Mayweather automatically get to be pfp number 2 after having Marquez move up 2 weight classes to fight him?

Mayweather came back after a 2 year layoff and took the #2 spotfrom Marquez regardless of the circumstances of that fight.

It just about sums up how **** Ring Magazine's rankings are!