Did Castillo beat Mayweather the first time?

[Doctor_Tenma]

they've done countless polls on this site and many other sites and the decision is unanimous: the majority of fans believe castillo won, and when I say majority I mean like 75%

That's because Mayweather is hated. Can't take that poll into consideration.

[BEEHOP]

That's because Mayweather is hated. Can't take that poll into consideration.

Agreed, if JLC was viewed as Mayweather is on here than the poll would have been reversed.


Floyd won both fights.

[el malo]

Yes castillo won, floyd was what berto is now to hbo back then. but this topic has been done to death.

[BEEHOP]

Yes castillo won, floyd was what berto is now to hbo back then. but this topic has been done to death.

How did Castillo win when he lost?

[them_apples]

Agreed, if JLC was viewed as Mayweather is on here than the poll would have been reversed.


Floyd won both fights.

no it wouldn't have, look at the look on FMJ's face after that fight, he looked like a beaten man.

Castillo was really thumping him around the first time. FMJ came back and beat him fair and square though, so much for that.

[revs1227]

we have done polls on this before and castillo always comes out on top ..majority of the fans thought castillo won for whatever reason but floyd won the rematch and this 1 "loss" really dont mean ****

[BEEHOP]

we have done polls on this before and castillo always comes out on top ..majority of the fans thought castillo won for whatever reason but floyd won the rematch and this 1 "loss" really dont mean ****

It's not even a loss. Castillo didn't win the early rounds.

[Syf]

we have done polls on this before and castillo always comes out on top ..majority of the fans thought castillo won for whatever reason but floyd won the rematch and this 1 "loss" really dont mean ****

As said before...Polls with the word "Mayweather" in them are NOT reliable online