James Toney says he would KO Prime Mike Tyson :0

[famicommander]

It's easy to make claims that can never be tested.

[MalevolentBite]

It's easy to make claims that can never be tested.

He's entitled to his opinion, like everyone else.

[Spray_resistant]

I am a big fan of Toney and he is more skilled in many ways than Mike who is 1 diminesional but he had so much natural talent that he would blow Toney out in a rd or 2 at best.

[hugh grant]

I am a big fan of Toney and he is more skilled in many ways than Mike who is 1 diminesional but he had so much natural talent that he would blow Toney out in a rd or 2 at best.

No, I think toney is so much better than most Tyson faced. But a stoppage is possible for tyson. Definitely Tyson wins though

[IronDanHamza]

No, I think toney is so much better than most Tyson faced. But a stoppage is possible for tyson. Definitely Tyson wins though

You need a brain to think.

Which would explain this incredibly dumb opinion.

[Spray_resistant]

No, I think toney is so much better than most Tyson faced. But a stoppage is possible for tyson. Definitely Tyson wins though

Even if he is much more skilled he is not a real HW, he was a butterball above Cruiser even at Crusier he looked soft. I doubt he would be able to do anything to stop a peak Tyson from steamrolling him. I say this as a big fan of Toney

[TheProudLunatic]

Tyson would kill Toney. Christ LOL

Since this is a fantasy match, let's fantaSIZE Toney being a natural HW in his prime

[IronDanHamza]

Since this is a fantasy match, let's fantaSIZE Toney being a natural HW in his prime

You don't need to fantasize because they both fought at HW.

You know, the one where you said "for certain" that Toney has a better HW resume than Tyson

What is your favourite colour, 4?

[MalevolentBite]

Since this is a fantasy match, let's fantaSIZE Toney being a natural HW in his prime

Hmmmmmm. Ok.

In an alternate time zone. If James Toney was a heavyweight at his current height and weighed around 210-220lbs? He was 219 against holyfield and 239 in Rahman 1.

I think he would only defeat Mike Tyson after the buster Douglas fight. Not pre buster Douglas. I think the mentally fit mike tyson that got used to feasting on bums and washed up champions from the 80s would be too much offensively for James Toney and win on the cards. But the mike tyson that got folded by Douglas and the tyson after that fight, yea Toney would beat that tyson.

James Toney is too defensive fighter that sometimes gets hit too often because he has a good chin. I think to beat that tyson. You gotta fight fire with fire. When buster Douglas got up from the canvas he was ready to risk it all. I am sorry but James toney mentally sometimes isnt there.

[IronDanHamza]

Hmmmmmm. Ok.

In an alternate time zone. If James Toney was a heavyweight at his current height and weighed around 210-220lbs? He was 219 against holyfield and 239 in Rahman 1.

I think he would only defeat Mike Tyson after the buster Douglas fight. Not pre buster Douglas. I think the mentally fit mike tyson that got used to feasting on bums and washed up champions from the 80s would be too much offensively for James Toney and win on the cards. But the mike tyson that got folded by Douglas and the tyson after that fight, yea Toney would beat that tyson.

James Toney is more so too defensive fighter that sometimes thats too many hits. I think to beat that tyson. You gotta fight fire with fire. When buster Douglas got up from the canvas he was ready to risk it all. I am sorry but James toney mentally sometimes isnt there.

What about if Mike Tyson was the same Mike Tyson but 7'2 and 500 lbs?

It's a non sensical stupid argument because the thing you are describing doesn't and never has existed.

James Toney wasn't even good enough to win a Light Heavyweight trinket in his prime and you somehow think that person can go up to Heavyweight and beat a 1991 version of Mike Tyson?