Who did better against Floyd: Pacquiao or Maidana?

[Smash]

odd poll considering some people thought maidana beat or at least deserved a draw v floyd

[Smash]

It’s not clear.

ok lol

[just the facts]

Both best floyd arguably. But my aunty who I was watching fight with was pleading with ref to save Floyd from further punishment against the cruel maidana. Plus maidens got his rematch. So id say maidens did better.
Although floyd fans will say maidens fight was closer that's why he got rematch, whereas floyd was most likely scared of pac more and took money and ran from pac. Quit whilst ahead so to speak

This poster is more limited in the intelligence department than any other poster I’ve seen in my years here and that’s saying a lot.

[just the facts]

I do not recall Floyd vs Cotto like that or some late surge from Cotto? If anything it came from Floyd.
I recall Floyd winning early, Cotto making adjustments and taking the middle rounds then Floyd made adjustments and pulled away in the late rounds.
From memory it was competitive through 9 then all Floyd

To answer op; Maidana did a lot better.
I gave Maidana 5 rounds (1st fight), from memory I think I only gave Manny 3

I’ve been here for a decade. In that time every post you make here has been unbiased, truthful and intelligent.

[SouthpawRight]

This poster is more limited in the intelligence department than any other poster I’ve seen in my years here and that’s saying a lot.

but my aunty said that’s how the fight went

lol

[Bennyleonard99]

Well, Floyd handpicked Maidana twice and both looked like business set ups. Floyd had to be forced to fight Pac by the head of CBS Showtime Les Moonves. Yes the Floyd Maidana fights looked competitive but so did Creed vs Balboa and Lang vs Balboa. Pac Floyd looked like Floyd boxed to survive 12 because he knew the Vegas judges were bought.

[Hustle]

Well, Floyd handpicked Maidana twice and both looked like business set ups. Floyd had to be forced to fight Pac by the head of CBS Showtime Les Moonves. Yes the Floyd Maidana fights looked competitive but so did Creed vs Balboa and Lang vs Balboa. Pac Floyd looked like Floyd boxed to survive 12 because he knew the Vegas judges were bought.

Who needs bought judges when you win so easily? Hbo side of the commentary team even had pac losing. And they were pac fanboys

[Hustle]

I do not recall Floyd vs Cotto like that or some late surge from Cotto? If anything it came from Floyd.
I recall Floyd winning early, Cotto making adjustments and taking the middle rounds then Floyd made adjustments and pulled away in the late rounds.
From memory it was competitive through 9 then all Floyd

To answer op; Maidana did a lot better.
I gave Maidana 5 rounds (1st fight), from memory I think I only gave Manny 3

Same fights I was watching. In real time

I had Floyd vs cotto 116-112 Floyd
I had Floyd vs pac 117-111 floyd
I had floyd vs maidana 115-113 floyd

[SouthpawRight]

Same fights I was watching. In real time

I had Floyd vs cotto 116-112 Floyd
I had Floyd vs pac 117-111 floyd
I had floyd vs maidana 115-113 floyd

me

Floyd 9-3’d Miguel
Floyd 8-4’d Marcos
Floyd 10-2’d Manny

as for his other competitive bouts

Floyd 9-3’d Marcos
Floyd 8-4’d Oscar
Floyd 7-5’d Jose

[Ctx94]

Who needs bought judges when you win so easily? Hbo side of the commentary team even had pac losing. And they were pac fanboys

it wasn’t easy though because the commentators for showtime said Floyd was running in the beginning

his daddy said he was fighting scared and not acting like his self in the middle rounds

and manny had him bleeding from the mouth where as he didn’t even scratch manny despite being the significantly bigger man