At 147-154, Prime for Prime, how would Floyd Mayweather Jr fair against these five Pro Boxers he beat in the past?

[djtmal]

Floyd didn’t duck anyone.

Compare the resumes. Baldo was the real champion. You know the Ring champion- the guy that beat the guy. He also had the WBC belt.

Margs had a fake belt. He was the paper champ.

What prime, great natural welterweight did Floyd fight/beat

It definitely wasn't the guy who was the Ring/WBC Champ

[QueensburyRules]

- - l'l floydy was Haymon's TBA short notice TBE TUE boytoy.

Never seen a growed fighter of any class stop in the middle of a fight to go squallin' fer he CrackDaddy.

Sissies in my day always went squallin' to mommy, but hey, it's a new soft lad era in boxing. l'l floydy fit the mold letting Logan Paul pound him from pillar to post after guaranteeing for he soft lad fans to bet on he knocking out Paul. Didn't even bother to refund since soft lads love to fill up he shorts with dollar bills...

[ELPacman]

I got Mayweather losing to Pac and Oscar. MAYBE Mosley can do something cause he was very fast too, but maybe a tad inconsistent or hittable.

I would still have Mayweather beating Cotto though. I think Cotto did actually better when he faced Mayweather at the time they did than if they were lighter weights. Cotto showed that he had issues facing faster guys at the lighter weight. Even with the wins he got, they weren't that easy.

Young Oscar was very fast and had a real good jab. He showed he could disrupt Mayweather with it in their fight, but just stopped using it.

Pac had a shoulder injury and was already removed from his prime years (let's not forget he had already been flattened by Marquez), so we have no idea how a 100% healthy Pac would have gone, but it sure as hell wouldn't have looked the way it did. Pac said he literally went into surgery immediately after the fight to get it repaired.

BTW, anyone that has or had a shoulder injury in their life would understand this. I've got both shoulders shot and the connective tissues are no longer there that would allow me to throw a punch with the same force as when they were fine. I also cannot bench because my left tear now removed the connectivity. I literally press and there is almost no feeling of strength in my left arm because of it. I've given up on bench press. Whether or not the Mayweather camp knew doesn't matter anymore. I just see it as a stained win and non representative of what would have occurred if he faced a 100% healthy, younger Pac (let's say prior to the Marquez KO).

[djtmal]

I got Mayweather losing to Pac and Oscar. MAYBE Mosley can do something cause he was very fast too, but maybe a tad inconsistent or hittable.

I would still have Mayweather beating Cotto though. I think Cotto did actually better when he faced Mayweather at the time they did than if they were lighter weights. Cotto showed that he had issues facing faster guys at the lighter weight. Even with the wins he got, they weren't that easy.

Young Oscar was very fast and had a real good jab. He showed he could disrupt Mayweather with it in their fight, but just stopped using it.

Pac had a shoulder injury and was already removed from his prime years (let's not forget he had already been flattened by Marquez), so we have no idea how a 100% healthy Pac would have gone, but it sure as hell wouldn't have looked the way it did. Pac said he literally went into surgery immediately after the fight to get it repaired.

BTW, anyone that has or had a shoulder injury in their life would understand this. I've got both shoulders shot and the connective tissues are no longer there that would allow me to throw a punch with the same force as when they were fine. I also cannot bench because my left tear now removed the connectivity. I literally press and there is almost no feeling of strength in my left arm because of it. I've given up on bench press. Whether or not the Mayweather camp knew doesn't matter anymore. I just see it as a stained win and non representative of what would have occurred if he faced a 100% healthy, younger Pac (let's say prior to the Marquez KO).

Floyd was never fighting a 100% healthy, younger Pac. Just wasn't going to happen.

Maaaybe he would have considered it after Margarito because he looked more vulnerable but the version that beat the brakes off Oscar Hatton and Cotto he was too scared

[BodyBagz]

And with relative ease.

Nothing changes.

If May had just a little more power....

[BodyBagz]

Mosley's biggest win was beating Oscar De La Hoya in his prime

Robbery
IIRC, Mosley's reaction to the decision was shock and awe
Pac fought the worst version of Mosley

[djtmal]

Robbery
IIRC, Mosley's reaction to the decision was shock and awe

He soundly outpointed Oscar

[Echo Hawk]

He ducked Manny and used blood work for an excuse
He ducked the Oscar rematch Oscar fought him too close for comfort
prime undefeated Cotto called him out but he was "on vacation"
Mosley called him out at lightweight the pretty boy version the Floyd boys salivate over, but Floyd said he was chasing some defenses record

Forgot about that. He retired a year and one day to nullify the rematch clause.

[Roadblock]

Forgot about that. He retired a year and one day to nullify the rematch clause.

Might have been to get his life in order, but youre so wise and know his situation personally on all levels so you must know how it is, you couldnt be one of those brain dead humans that believe gossip, social media and the orchestrated narrative pushed by media that actually brainwashes the easily lead impressionable young folk, nah youre to smart for that young and dumb phase that science says is because of slower brain development in forms of reasoning and logic in youth.

I think you must be a genius.

[The D3vil]

Old Oscar almost beat him, so the Oscar who got robbed against Trinidad would do even better.

Mosley hurt him at 38, so I'm taking him too

He beats Canelo, Cotto, and Pacquaio